| Prince Charlie Crosses 
    Swarkestone Bridge  by Jeff Provine 
     Author 
    says: we're very pleased to present a new story from Jeff Provine's 
    excellent blog This 
    Day in Alternate History. Please note that the opinions expressed in 
    this post do not necessarily reflect the views of the author(s). 
     
      On December 6th 1745,
     
      Please click the
        
        
          
           icon to Stumble Upon the Today in Alternate History web site.Bonnie 
        
        Prince Charlie crossed the Swarkestone Bridge 
 In England's Revolution of 1688, often termed the “Glorious Revolution”, 
        
        the Stuart dynasty was removed from the English and Scottish thrones once 
        
        more, this time deposed by William of Orange at the invitation of 
        
        Parliament. The Catholic kings of a Protestant nation had been a struggle 
        
        through the seventeenth century, but many in Britain felt that the Stuarts 
        
        would be best upon the throne, especially as non-English-speaking Germans 
        
        from Hanover began to rule. The Stuart Cause would continue, even after 
        
        “The Fifteen”, a bungled invasion by James III & VII after which the Old 
        
        Pretender was no longer welcome in France as an embarrassment.
 
 Prince Charles Edward Stuart (fondly known as “Bonnie Prince Charlie”) had 
        
        been trained for war since his birth. He witnessed sieges, studied with 
        
        commanders, and took up pursuit of the generalship that would win him back 
        
        his throne. While his father was the exiled king, James III & VII still 
        
        had enough influence to persuade France into sending an invasion fleet in 
        
        1744. In preparation, Prince Regent Charles went to Scotland and began to 
        
        raise his army of supporters. While the French invasion never 
        
        materialized, Charlie decided to carry out the reconquest of Britain 
        
        himself in 1745.
 
 With two ships and an army of eight men, Charlie landed at Eriskay on July 
        
        23. Finding great support among the Highlanders, Charlie raised his 
        
        father's standard and formed up an army large enough to subdue Edinburgh. 
        
        At Prestonpans on September 21, Charlie met with the only government army 
        
        to stand against him in Scotland, which he soundly defeated, inflicting 
        
        ten times the causalities his force took. From there, he pressed south, 
        
        moving practically unopposed with 6,000 men through Cumbria and Derbyshire 
        
        to Swarkestone Bridge. There, word said that few supported him in the 
        
        south and, worse, the government was building a mass of force to 
        
        counterattack. Charlie's commanders advised him to turn back and raise 
        
        more of his own support.
 
 Charlie decided to ignore them and pressed southward while momentum was 
        
        with him. It was found that few did support him in the south, but few 
        
        supported the Hannovers as well. As winter settled, Charlie made for 
        
        London, hoping to besiege the city during its hungriest time. His only 
        
        obstacle was a force comparable in size to his own, though hastily 
        
        assembled, led by King George II's son, the Duke of Cumberland. They met 
        
        at Hatfield on December 18, where Charlie's Highlanders made use of the 
        
        ancient woods to minimize the effect of the government cannon. When the 
        
        battle was won, Charlie seized the cannon and turned it on London for the 
        
        winter siege.
 
 By spring, the city was in an uproar against Parliament. Without hope of 
        
        fresh food coming that spring, the winter starvation would grow even 
        
        worse. Charlie welcomed anyone who would desert the city and join his 
        
        cause, strengthening his ranks with generous Christmas and New Years' 
        
        feasts. Finally, on April 16, Parliament conceded and voted to reinstate 
        
        the House of Stuart and oust George II. Charlie's father James would be 
        
        crowned later that year and rule until his death in 1766. The aged James 
        
        was feared as being a Catholic tyrant, but he proved largely ineffectual, 
        
        his most vivacious act being to keep Britain out of the Prussian War, 
        
        where Frederick the Great established himself as a power on the Continent.
 
 Charlie, meanwhile, traveled the British Colonies in hopes of expansion. 
        
        He toured the Americas, also helping to establish the legitimacy of the 
        
        Stuarts, and joined Robert Clive on his second journey in India. During 
        
        his time in England, he converted to Anglicanism, which enraged his father 
        
        but set many British minds at ease. Upon being crowned in 1766, Charles 
        
        III began ambitious projects to expand British trade and endorsed 
        
        exploration for new routes and potential settlements, especially in North 
        
        America and in the Pacific with Admiral Cook's five voyages. His rigorous 
        
        expansion inevitably led to further wars with the Dutch and French, 
        
        expensive naval campaigns that drained the treasury of all.
 
 When Parliament attempted to levy heavier taxes, uproar rose among the 
        
        American colonists in the early 1780s with calls for representation, 
        
        perhaps even independence. It is said that Charlie was fearful of losing 
        
        his crown after fighting to win it, and he went quickly to work adding 
        
        American seats to Parliament to guarantee his support. His “weakness” 
        
        would be severely criticized by many Tories, but the heavy hand of the 
        
        French king Louis XVI would lead to the brutal revolution in 1791.
 
 Charlie stayed quiet through the remainder of his reign, depending more 
        
        upon prime ministers such as William Pitt. His son Charles IV succeeded 
        
        the throne upon his death in 1798, the same year the Egyptian War sparked 
        
        as Republican France attempted to strike at India through the Suez. Upon 
        
        the sound defeat of France and the seizure of many of its colonial claims, 
        
        the nineteenth century would stand as the next golden age of Britain, 
        
        continuing Charlie's legacy of progressive economics and social 
        
        liberality.
 
 
 
     
     Author 
    says in reality Bonnie Prince Charlie retreated from the south at 
    Swarkestone. The retreat gave time for the Duke of Cumberland actually to 
    form an army such as they feared, and he would take up pursuit of Charlie 
    until the Young Pretender's defeat at Culloden on April 16, 1746. Charlie 
    would escape from Scotland in disguise and return to exile as a broken man. 
    He took mistresses, reportedly drank heavily, and his physical abuse of his 
    wife Princess Louise of Stolberg-Gedern drove her away. His brother Henry IX 
    became a cardinal, outlived him, and, never taking a wife, would be the last 
    of the Royal House of Stuart. To view guest historian's comments on this 
    post please visit the
    
    Today in Alternate History web site. 
 
     Jeff Provine, Guest Historian of
    
    Today in Alternate History, a Daily Updating Blog of Important Events In 
    History That Never Occurred Today. Follow us on
    
    Facebook, Myspace and
    Twitter.  Imagine what would be, if history had occurred a bit 
    differently. Who says it didn't, somewhere? These fictional news items 
    explore that possibility. Possibilities such as America becoming a Marxist 
    superpower, aliens influencing human history in the 18th century and Teddy 
    Roosevelt winning his 3rd term as president abound in this interesting 
    fictional blog. 
 
 
    
    Sitemetre  
    
     |