Made in Vietnam
by Jeff Provine
Author
says: we're very pleased to present a new story from Jeff Provine's
excellent blog This
Day in Alternate History. Please note that the opinions expressed in
this post do not necessarily reflect the views of the author(s).
November 2nd 1967,
on this day the Wise Men Recommend Focusing on the Tunnel, Not the Light.
War in French Indochina, later Vietnam, had been raging for almost twenty
years. It had begun as campaigns against colonial domination and developed
into a movement supporting the growth of Communism.
Wise Men Recommend Focusing on the
Tunnel, Not the Light Determined to check the Domino Theory, the US
first began to send military advisers in 1950 and surged US troops into
involvement under the Kennedy Administration. With war still sitting at a
stalemate in Korea, Washington approved only of the idea of a "limited
war" rather than a bloody northward invasion like the one pushed by
MacArthur ten years before.
As the years dragged on, more and more American soldiers came home under
their flag, and the public began to question why troops were there in the
first place, President Lyndon Johnson sought help in solving the war
weariness. He called a meeting of "The Wise Men", a group of political and
business leaders who had formed under Truman's administration to dictate
American foreign policy. Theirs had been the plan of containment and
anti-communism that had guided the early days of the Cold War. Originally
powerful bankers, lawyers, and diplomats, the men considered themselves
statesmen needed to advise elected officials.
"They'd have been smarter to tell LBJ to make sure
this was a Navy and Marines op...most Americans tend to think of the Army
as _ours,_ while the Navy and Marines are not so much. Also, _not_ using
conscripted troops in Vietnam would have avoided a lot of trouble...before
Vietnam, most young men expected to be conscripted/serve, and it was
really no big huge deal. Once you had the inequities and risks of the war,
though, trouble reared its ugly head. " - reader's commentLBJ
called a conference on the first of November in which the Wise Men were
briefed about the situation at hand. The notables included General Omar
Bradley, General Maxwell Taylor, Justice Abe Fortas, and Henry Cabot
Lodge, Jr., among many others. There was progress being made in Vietnam,
but the battlefield casualties wore away at American public support. The
Wise Men agreed that simple departure from Vietnam was unacceptable and
the influence of communism needed to be held back. While some suggested a
positive PR campaign, after much discussion and a brandy or two, they
decided that a more aggressive method than simple reassurance was
necessary.
Please click
to comment on Reddit.The men dusted off old recommendations from
the days of Wilson's war effort. While propaganda machines had changed
over the last fifty years, many of the ideas still stood. LBJ and the War
Department began to lead calls of an end to the attacks from North
Vietnam, echoing speeches of the Minute Men of the 1910s denouncing the
Kaiser. Rather than focusing on numbers, stories of war heroes were
brought to the forefront of war news. The public reacted in a dower
opinion, still skeptical of the war but not that American troops should be
there.
When the Tet Offensive began January 31, 1968, LBJ became vindicated. The
press carried stories of the overwhelming atrocities in the sudden Viet
Cong attacks. Battles raged for two months, and the American public threw
their support behind the troops with marches and calls for reinforcements.
The second and third waves of attack began that summer, and the Americans
regrouped, taking back much of the gained territory. While a tactical
success initially, the Tet Offensive would prove a strategic loss, and the
VC found themselves nearly devoid of supplies.
At the time of election, the American public seemed torn whether to turn
toward the Republicans calling for an end to the war or the Democrats with
their strategy of counterstrike to defend foreign allies. The polls came
in very close with Hubert Humphrey narrowly defeating former
Vice-President Richard Nixon. Within months of Humphrey taking office, the
proposal for ceasefire would be announced, and a demilitarized zone along
the 14th Parallel would be drawn separating the two countries akin to that
in Korea.
South Vietnam would match its predecessor South Korea as a bastion of
capitalism and industry. Under the Humphrey administration, a great deal
of economic influence would flow to Vietnam, and its cheap factories would
prove to outpace Japanese production of inexpensive goods in the 1990s.
The tag "Made in Vietnam" is seemingly ubiquitous among high tech
electronics today.
Author
says in reality the Wise Men recommended a PR campaign focusing on the
light at the end of the tunnel of the Vietnam War. Announcements were
focused on positive figures and optimism, showing that the war would soon be
over. When the Tet Offensive showed a renewed push of Viet Cong aggression,
the American public turned on LBJ, and all hope for the war seemed lost. As
Nixon came to the White House, American troop withdrawal began, and Vietnam
would fall to communism in 1975. To view guest historian's comments on this
post please visit the
Today in Alternate History web site.
Jeff Provine, Guest Historian of
Today in Alternate History, a Daily Updating Blog of Important Events In
History That Never Occurred Today. Follow us on
Facebook, Myspace and
Twitter.
Imagine what would be, if history had occurred a bit
differently. Who says it didn't, somewhere? These fictional news items
explore that possibility. Possibilities such as America becoming a Marxist
superpower, aliens influencing human history in the 18th century and Teddy
Roosevelt winning his 3rd term as president abound in this interesting
fictional blog.
Sitemetre
|