The Key West-Havana Tunnel
by Amerigo Vespucci
"Go south, young man, and vacation with the country."
New York Times Op-Ed, August 27, 1997
The drive south from Miami is a crowded one. Whether you make it in a minivan,
sports car, or a Ford-built Ferrari, the traffic is what sticks in your mind.
Eight lanes, bumper-to-bumper, filled with Americans and Canadians heading
south to the hot spots of the Florida Keys and beyond that, to Cuba. Driving
through the upper Keys is much like driving through Homestead -- brief
glimpses of exit-ramp diners, gas stations, and truck stops. The differences
stand out, however. There's no skyscraper-lined horizon, and swamps surround
the raised lanes of I-95 for much of the trip. The small towns of Key Largo,
Layton, and Marathon are dominated by the concrete construction of I-95, the
interstate that they serve, and is their sole reason for existence. Few
drivers note the beautiful reefs of John Pennekamp State Park or the white
sandy beaches of Coco Plum -- their eyes are south, to the casinos and lights
of Cuba.
At the Seven Mile Bridge there is a tieup, as always. Here, the highway
narrows from eight lanes to four, and the traffic slows to a crawl. Tempers
flare, but not to the road-rage proportions of northern drivers. After all,
this is a vacation, or so parents tell their children, and Key West is only an
hour away. From Big Pine Key south, the impatient crawl allows those
vacationers to get a glimpse of the Florida Keys as they might have been
before the highways encroached upon these small islands. But it's only a
glimpse, as traffic soon speeds up and the scenery blurs by the windows. Only
the vast, blue ocean remains the same, its azure brilliance contrasting with
the worn concrete of the interstate.
Few of those who travel the route to Havana bother to stop and gawk at the
immense steel and stone bridges built over a century ago, the first rope that
linked the Florida Keys to the mainland. Few stop and think that those
bridges, built by Henry Flagler in the early years of the 20th century, are
the forebears of the I-95 extension and the tunnel beyond. Those who do stop
rarely bother with more than a quick picture and perhaps a T-shirt with the
phrase "Got steel?" and a picture of the rusted old Bahia Honda bridge. They
almost never venture down to the surface roads of the Lower Keys, where coral
islands house those who work along the highway or in Key West.
As I-95 nears Boca Chica Key, the northern terminus of the Havana-Key West
Tunnel, the road once again widens to eight lanes, speeding traffic along
towards the orderly chaos of the Key West Terminal, a modern marvel scarcely
less impressive than the tunnel itself. The terminal encompasses eight acres,
an area nearly as great as that of the city of Key West, whose population of
30,000 is dwarfed by the ten million people who funnel through the tunnel
annually. Those ten million visitors bring with them over five million cars
and trucks, all of which must be transported across the hundred-mile distance
between Boca Chica Key and Hershey, Cuba, the southern terminus of the tunnel.
Upon arriving at the terminal, visitors and their cars are funneled into
separate waiting lots, based on when their train is scheduled to depart. The
loading and unloading of hundreds of automobiles per train is no small task,
and only the strict ticketing system of the Tunnel Authority keeps the train
schedule from descending into chaos. Tickets must be purchased in advance, and
travelers must arrive well in advance of their scheduled train. Experienced
travelers know to purchase their tickets far ahead of time, as costs mount
dramatically the closer to the travel date. Those foolish enough to purchase
tickets at the station are charged a premium and usually placed on the very
first train the next morning -- unless there's a cancellation or a no-show.
With so much demand, every spot must be filled, and traveling stand-by is
usually a recipe for disappointment.
When the announcement for the next train comes, Tunnel Authority supervisors
funnel cars and passengers into their designated spots. Drivers travel
separately from their automobiles, which are loaded into car wagons expertly
loaded by workers who do the same thing every day. Occasionally, mishaps occur
and delays happen. Trains later on in the day have a greater chance to run
late, but every night at midnight the slate is wiped clean and the schedule
reset. During summer, when demand is lighter, fewer trains run. During winter,
it seems as if half of North America is on Boca Chica Key.
Sometimes the wait seems interminable, but eventually all the passengers and
cars are loaded, the stand-by seats are filled, and the high-speed train
begins its run. Two hours later, you're in Cuba, land of rum, pineapples,
casinos, and vacations.
From Carlito's Dream: The Story of the Florida Straits Tunnel, Random House,
New York, New York, 2007.
-----------
When Henry Flagler first imagined a railroad line connecting Key West to the
rest of the United States in the waning years of the 19th century, he was
perceived a madman. "Flagler's Folly" was laughed at in newspapers both North
and South, and though this was a man who had built his fortune during the
Civil War and helped found Standard Oil, many doubted that his dream would
ever see reality. But this was a man who had already made half of Florida his
kingdom. During the Gilded Age, New York City socialites eager to escape
winter's grasp had fled south to Florida. Flagler had taken advantage of this,
building railroads and constructing magnificent hotels all along Florida's
east coast. With Key West, however, it seemed as though he had taken one step
too far.
The Spanish-American War changed all of that. Suddenly, the United States
found itself with dozens of new territories in the Caribbean, and as Theodore
Roosevelt's plan for a canal across Panama gained steam, there became a demand
for ports to connect shipping through the canal with the United States at
large. The man who could create a viable deep-water port far enough south
could become rich on the profits earned from that shipping. "Flagler's Folly"
suddenly appeared to be economically viable.
Over the next decade, Flagler worked to make his dream a reality. Working with
architects, engineers, and thousands of laborers, he built the Overseas
railway, a line of steel connecting the hamlet of Miami with Florida's largest
city -- Key West. Completed in 1912, the railway was hailed as the eighth
wonder of the world, and was widely acclaimed by the same newspapers that
called it a "folly" scarcely a decade before. "Time and space have been
conquered," trumpeted one newspaper.
Unfortunately, even before Flagler's death in 1913, the railroad was clearly
on shaky financial ground. New oil-fired steamships eliminated the need for a
coaling stop in Key West, and could carry more cargo. In addition, the
deep-water Port of Tampa was better connected by rail to the rest of the
United States, and because its construction had not been as expensive as the
Overseas Railway, it could charge less for transportation. When a 1935
hurricane devastated the railway, the railroad company was financially unable
to rebuild and sold the remaining spans to the state of Florida, which built a
highway on top of the railway bridges.
Given the federal designation U.S. 1, the highway would serve the Florida Keys
relatively unchanged for over thirty years. Two politicians, one in Cuba and
the other in Florida, would change all of that.
------------
The year 1960 was a politically tumultuous year on both sides of the Florida
Strait. In the United States, the presidential election between John F.
Kennedy and Richard Nixon was as contentious a contest as anyone could
remember. Heading into the November election, however, the good-looking
Kennedy appeared to have decisively won the nation's first televised debate
against a visibly uncomfortable Richard Nixon. Further south, in Cuba, the
conflict was less one of words and more one of guns and bullets. There, former
president Fulgencio Batista ruled the country as a dictator behind the scenes
of the official president, Andres Rivero Aguero, who had defeated Ramon Grau
in a protested election two years previous. The primary opposition to their
rule came from communist-supported rebels under the command of Raul Castro,
whose brother had been killed four years previous while attempting to return
to Cuba from a Mexican exile. Several other important rebel leaders had also
been killed when their boat, the Granma, had been sunk by a Cuban gunboat.
By November 1960, the situation had almost reached the boiling point. Though
resistance to Batista's rule was not organized under any one banner, it was
numerous enough to present a threat to the stability of the government. On
November 17, 1960, only four days after ordering a further harsh crackdown on
dissident groups, Fulgencio Batista was assassinated when his car was
destroyed in an explosion triggered by opposition group. The Cuban government
immediately fragmented, with no fewer than seventeen different groups vying
for power in the country. Lame-duck President Dwight Eisenhower pledged the
support of the United States for Aguero, the official leader of the country.
Aguero proved surprisingly effective in derailing the many factions attempting
to seize power. To limit the various military coups that had been ignited or
were brewing, he pledged not to remove Batista family members or supporters
from their positions. To appeal to the various liberal and leftist groups in
the country, he announced that as soon as was possible, he would return
constitutional authority to the country, which had been operating under a
suspended constitution for several years. In addition, he pledged to convene a
constitutional convention. He quietly informed each of the Batista and
military factions that this was simply a ruse to allow their faction to seize
more power. After having been seen as Batista's puppet for so many years, few
of the factions had any thought beyond Aguero being their puppet as well. None
believed that he could make it on his own. And to those who didn't respond to
any of his diplomatic efforts, he offered the barrel of a gun.
By the time John F. Kennedy was inaugurated on January 20, 1961, Aguero had
isolated, killed off, or drawn to him each of the major factions vying for
control in Cuba. Only Castro's communist faction lay beyond his grasp, but
even it had been wracked by defections in the wake of Batista's death as
various groups fought over the best way to take advantage of the situation. By
November 1962, two years after the assassination of Batista, Aguero could be
said to be the de facto ruler of Cuba, not just the figurehead he had been
before Batista's death. The constitutional convention he had convened in the
wake of the "troubles" as they were known, had turned real dividends in terms
of his ability to control Batista's more fervent followers, who were concerned
about what the liberalists and leftist might do if they managed to gain
control of the government. By playing off one side against the other, Aguero
was able to salvage a stable political and economic base for Cuba. American
dollars continued to flow south, and American tourists continued to visit what
had become a far quieter island. New casino projects continued to be
announced, and the "side benefits" that Aguero received from American
corporations were put to good use in helping to stabilize the country.
In the United States, President Kennedy's administration was an unremarkable
one, distinguished only by troubles in Laos and continued Republican
accusations that he was "soft on Communism," an accusation bolstered by
Kennedy's rapprochement with the Soviet leader, Nikita Krushchev. Though
Kennedy could point to success on the domestic front, the Republicans picked
up several seats in the mid-term Congressional elections. Perhaps the most
startling victory was that of dark horse candidate Carlito Gonzales for the
contested Florida Congressional seat. Born of Cuban parents, Gonzales had been
raised in Fort Lauderdale, a then-small town in southeast Florida. Gonzales
defeated heavy Republican favorite Emerson Rupert in the Republican primary,
then proceeded to win one of the closest elections in Florida history over
sitting Congressman George A. Smathers, a close friend of President Kennedy.
Gonzales's native Floridian background and his ability to appeal to white
voters put him over the top, as did his youth when compared with the
fifty-year-old Smathers. His attractive wife and children ironically reminded
voters of President Kennedy, despite the fact that the two men were members of
opposite parties.
Gonzales would be the beneficiary of one of the largest periods of economic
growth in Florida's history. Thanks to the widespread adoption of air
conditioning and an aging population, Florida became the vacation and
retirement center for the United States. Every year, tens of thousands of new
residents arrived from other states, drawn by good weather, a growing economy,
and other factors. Cuba, too, was a beneficiary of this boom, as the
stabilized political situation encouraged many Americans to vacation in Cuba.
The reinstatement of constitutional democracy and the announcement of the
first presidential election since 1958 fostered a belief that Cuba was safe
and a great place to visit. So great was the demand for ferries to service the
Key West-Havana route that World War II LSTs were pressed into service as
makeshift car ferries. Though many were in poor condition after twenty years
in storage and of limited seaworthiness, it was thought that they would prove
to be a useful interim solution until more ferries could be built.
On October 13, 1964, the Pride of Miami, formerly known as LST 466, set sail
from Key West to Havana. Moving at a stately 11 knots, she was scheduled to
arrive in Havana at 11 p.m. after a leisurely 8-hour ferry ride. She carried
17 cars, 3 trucks, and 345 passengers. It was an unusually heavy load for so
early in the fall, but the crew were eager for the business. Their ferry
company was being hard-pressed by several of the other ferry services that
operated the Havana route, most of which were operating newer, more
cost-effective ships. The Pride of Miami had been built in 1943 in Evansville,
Indiana, and had served in the South Pacific during the war, ferrying tanks
and men from island to island. After the war, it had been mothballed in
Norfolk, Virginia, and had been purchased in 1961 to serve as a car ferry to
Havana. Its engines were balky, the electrical system shot, and it handled
worse than most of the lobster boats that sailed daily from Key West, but it
was what was available, and so it served the growing tourist trade to Cuba.
The evening of the 13th began with fair weather and only scattered showers,
but as the evening turned to night, the weather began to worsen. Unbeknownst
to anyone aboard, Hurricane Isabell, which had been forecast to strike Belize
on the afternoon of the 14th, had taken a radical turn north, directly towards
the Florida Keys. Shortly after departing Key West, the Pride of Miami's radio
shorted out. To the crew aboard, it was just another in a long line of things
to be fixed. They were aware there was a hurricane out there, but it was
heading to Belize, and while it might make the crossing a little rough, it
certainly wouldn't interfere with the voyage.
By 8 p.m., however, most of the crew were beginning to believe that something
was wrong. Though they'd expected rough seas, these were beyond that, cresting
at ten feet at times. With every wave, the ship rolled and plunged. None of
the passengers had avoided seasickness, and the covered deck, never the
cleanest, sloshed with rainwater, seawater, and the vomit of seasick
passengers. Things would get much worse. Two hours later, winds were gusting
upwards of 70 miles and hour, and the ship was taking on water. Without a
functioning radio, no distress call could be sent, and though the lights of
Cuba could faintly be seen though the driving rain, the ship would never reach
those lights. At approximately 11:30, the chains that had secured the cars
aboard the Pride of Miami began to break with the force of the storm. Crashing
back and forth, they added their unstable weight to the rolling ship,
intensifying the ship's roll. With every wave, the ship oscillated more and
more. At 11:47 p.m. the captain gave the order to abandon ship. Many of the
flimsy life rafts couldn't be launched in the massive waves, wind, and driving
rain, and those that could be launched were launched half full. At
approximately midnight, the Pride of Miami gave up the ghost. After taking a
wave estimated at 30 feet over her port side, the ship capsized and sank,
taking 187 passengers and crew with her to the bottom of the ocean. Only the
close proximity of the Cuban shore allowed any of the passengers to survive.
In the wake of the disaster, politicians across Florida called for a reform of
the ferry industry in the state. In the final months of his run for
reelection, President Kennedy also seized upon the issue, and proposed an
investigation into the incident as well as funding for research into
replacements for the older ferries in use on the Havana route. The Pride of
Miami incident made Hurricane Isabell the deadliest American hurricane since
the 1935 Labor Day hurricane, the same storm that caused the bankruptcy of the
Overseas Railroad.
In addition to President Kennedy, Senator Carlito Gonzales also took up storm
prevention as his personal political crusade. In the run-up to the November
elections, bi-partisan support saw a multi-million dollar subsidy package
formed for the Havana ferries, money for the families of those killed, and
additional funding for the National Hurricane Center's forecasting department.
In Cuba, the reaction was much more sanguine. Cuba is hit by several
hurricanes a year on average, and though 11 Cuban citizens lost their lives on
the Pride of Miami, the nation's attention was focused on the upcoming
presidential and senatorial elections, the first in several years. Despite
that distraction, President Aguero did make a speech about the "tragedy in the
straits." Unremarked upon in the media was Aguero's declaration: "Perhaps one
day Cuba and the United States might be linked by a great bridge, preventing
tragedies like the one we are here to remember -- but until that date, we must
stay aware, alert, and conscious of the fact that only by being watchful can
we keep our sailors safe."
Those words went unnoticed in the United States, as was a small clause in the
Isabell Recovery Appropriations Act marked "Florida Strait Bridge."
Hidden in the hundred-page Act was that small listing, a $50,000 appropriation
inserted by a junior congressman from Louisiana who had a political backer in
the ocean surveying business. Perhaps surprisingly, the work was done capably,
with a thorough mapping of the Florida Straits from Key West to Havana being
done by a sonar sledge dragged behind a trawler. Even a few core samples of
the shore were taken, indicating a solid coral base below a layer of sediment.
The resulting 200-page report found its way to Senator Gonzales's desk in
Washington, where it was dutifully released in press-release format to the
South Florida media, which proceeded to write an inevitable series of
editorials denouncing waste and laughing at the idea of a bridge across the
Florida Strait, which the mapping had revealed to be over a mile deep at its
deepest points. Any bridge would have to float on the surface of the water,
thus making it vulnerable to the same hurricanes that sank the Pride of Miami.
For a few weeks in the fall of 1965, the report brought a fair bit of humor to
the editorial pages of South Florida's newspapers. An enterprising
entrepreneur printed "Florida Strait Bridge Authority" bumper stickers, which
sold at a fast pace. But it was a temporary laugh, and fairly soon Florida was
back to worrying about the growing war in Vietnam along with the rest of the
country. In Cuba, the economy continued to boom as the nation began to be
referred by many in the United States as "the Monaco of America" after the
small tourist-friendly European nation that based its economy on gaming and
good weather. Honest elections were held for the first time in nearly a
decade, and to the surprise of many outsiders, Carlos Prío Socarrás, who had
returned from a Batista-imposed exile, won an overwhelming victory. Aside from
minor Communist disturbances in the western mountains and grumbling among the
elite, who had backed Batista, the nation was at peace.
That peace did not extend to former Cuban president Andres Rivero Aguero, who
had been overwhelmingly turned out of office. The hand that he had nurtured
had bit him. He had honestly expected to remain in office, and had counted on
the gratitude of the liberals for restoring constitutional government. He had
not really believed in it as anything more than a tool to calm the country,
and now it had turned him out of office. If he had tried to protest, to remain
in power, no one would have accepted it -- even the army had been infected by
the germ of liberalization that had been nurtured by the booming economy.
Disgusted, Aguero left Cuba to serve as the CEO of an import/export
corporation in the Dominican Republic. After that company's bankruptcy in
1969, he was reduced to making public goodwill appearances on behalf of the
Cuban government, which paid him a nominal stipend.
In early 1970, Aguero visited Washington, D.C. as part of a "mission of
understanding." The trip basically equated to a two-week vacation for those
who went, paid for by the Cuban government. During the trip, Aguero dutifully
made a stop at Senator Gonzales's Washington office. While exchanging
pleasantries, Aguero noticed an unusual drawing of a bridge on Gonzales's
office wall. It was an artist's conception of a Florida Strait bridge, created
two years previous and kept by Gonzales to "remind him of the limitations of
human effort." Aguero became fascinated by the drawing to the point that
Gonzales offered to give it to Aguero. Though Aguero declined, the image stuck
with him well after his trip to Washington. Before he left, Gonzales gave him
a copy of the 200-page ocean floor survey of the Florida Strait as a parting
gift. Though it might have seemed an odd gift, Gonzales recognized Aguero's
interest, and it was a gift that Aguero greatly appreciated.
As a retired politician, he had ample time to explore the possibilities
presented by a permanent link between the United States and Cuba. The
opportunity was certainly there -- by 1972, more than three million cars were
being transported annually across the Florida Strait. Cuba had become a major
tourist destination for wealthy and middle-class Americans and Canadians eager
to escape the crowded beaches of Florida. In addition, Cuba's comparatively
lax drug, alcohol, and gaming laws provided entertainment options that simply
weren't available in either the United States or Canada. Adventurous European
tourists interested in finding something different from what could be found in
Spain, southern France, or Italy, also began to travel to Cuba. Though their
numbers were small at first, they would become a not insignificant part of the
tourist trade by the mid-1990s.
These facts were clear to Aguero, as was the fact that a bridge, if
constructed, could earn its builder immense profits. But the problem was that
such a bridge was impossible. The 1965 survey clearly showed that the average
depth of the Florida Strait was over half a mile deep -- far too deep for any
bridge pilings. A floating bridge was clearly out of the question, due to the
hurricane threat. Though discouraged by the impossibility of a bridge, he
began to investigate tunnel options instead. The Cuban government, only too
eager to bury the remnants of the Batista era, in 1972 created a small
committee to investigate the possibility of a permanent link between the
Florida Keys and Cuba. With Aguero at its head, he would be shuffled safely
away from politics and in a position to do no more harm to the government. The
committee was funded with a nominal budget, and secretly, Aguero was pleased.
He had no desire to reenter politics, regardless of what the Cuban government
might have feared. The bridge/tunnel project was just the thing to keep him
occupied, and he plunged into it with full enthusiasm.
He and the two engineers he was able to hire threw themselves into the project
whole-heartedly. Despite his limited budget, Aguero visited tunnels around the
world, and looked at the plans for some of the most ambitious projects being
undertaken around the world. From the initial drillings of the Seikan tunnel
in Japan to the plans for the Channel Tunnel to the inner workings of the
decade-old Chesapeake Bay Bridge-Tunnel, the committee examined it all. But
all the tunnels they visited were inadequate. They were too short, too
shallow, or impractical for the Florida Strait. As Aguero's initial enthusiasm
began to fade, he began to examine more and more radical ideas: the plans for
the Bering Strait bridge, the Messina Bridge, and other grand projects. By
late 1976, Aguero was ready to admit defeat. The Florida Strait was simply too
long, too deep, and too unstable to allow for any existing tunnel design to be
used.
To make matters worse, the worldwide economic recession caused by the OPEC oil
embargo had begun to affect the Cuban economy. With less money available for
tourism, the Cuban economy suffered from a drought of American dollars. In
addition, the rising price of gasoline made many Americans reluctant to take
long trips by car, including the drive to Key West and on the ferries across
to Havana. Many of the ferries, already suffering under high fuel prices, went
bankrupt as the flow of traffic evaporated. To fix the situation, the
government began to slash spending, hoping to equalize a growing deficit. One
of the items on the chopping block was Aguero's small bridge "committee."
On December 19, 1976, the last day before the Christmas holiday, Aguero and
his engineers met with Alan Grant, a young British engineer who had theorized
a new type of tunnel design the year previously. Called the Suspended Immersed
Tube (SIT), the design basically consisted of a long steel tube, constructed
in sections. The sections were to have a positive buoyancy, meaning they would
float if not held down. Cables would then be attached between the sectioned
tube and the ocean's floor, creating a design similar to that of a suspension
bridge, but using the principle of buoyancy instead of gravity. The design was
far cheaper than drilling through hard rock, and unlike a floating bridge,
could be constructed in areas where weather was a factor. The immersed design
meant that even in severe storms, like the hurricanes that plague the
Caribbean Sea, the tunnel would remain undisturbed. And thanks to the fact
that the tunnel could be positioned at any depth by lengthening or shortening
the cables, the design would avoid the problems associated with the Strait's
deep terrain.
Aguero and his engineers were intrigued by the idea, but did not take to it
right away. It was a new, untested idea, and had never been built, even in
test form. Grant was a young, enthusiastic engineer, but his relative
inexperience made Aguero pause. He had submitted a similar design to Italian
authorities seven years previous as part of a competition for a link
connecting Sicily to Italy via the Strait of Messina. He had been turned down.
After a hard day of questions and debate, Aguero and his engineers decided the
SIT tunnel was worth exploring further, if possible. The idea of the SIT
design dominated Aguero's mind throughout the Christmas and New Year's
holiday. By mid-January, Aguero had made up his mind. His two engineers could
find no fault with the plan other than its untested nature, and so Grant
returned to Cuba to detail his design in a lengthy plan.
Time was of the essence. Budget cuts had eliminated Aguero's little committee,
and after the beginning of the fiscal year on April 20, there would be no more
government money to continue the work. Their small Havana office would be
closed, turned over to some other government agency, and the engineers would
have to find other jobs. But if they could just come up with a design in time,
there might be a stay of execution for the group.
The four men worked day and night on the design, struggling through the lack
of information about the Strait. Though the American survey had done a
spectacular job in 1965 with so little in the way of funding, there was almost
no information about actual seabed conditions, and the mapping that had been
done a decade previously had been crippled by the limited technology then
available. They knew the depth of the water, but not whether the sea floor was
rocky, sandy, or lined with coral, as shoreside core samples indicated. As
April 20 approached, Aguero knew they would not be finished in time. It was
simply too massive a project to finish in just four months, and all four men
were exhausted. One day before the office was due to be closed, the four men
packed up their papers, equipment, and samples and moved it all to Aguero's
estate outside of Havana. Aguero had a small fortune amassed during his term
as President, but even he couldn't afford to pay the other three men and
provide funding for continued research.
As a result, in May, 1977, Aguero flew to Washington D.C. to visit with
Senator Gonzales, now in his third term as the senior Republican senator from
Florida. Outlining the work he was doing in Cuba, Aguero requested any
financial or logistical support that could be made available by the U.S.
government. But the United States too was going through a round of budget cuts
and suffering under the weight of stagflation. Furthermore, the new President,
former California Governor Jerry Brown, had promised to curb government
spending and balance the budget in an effort to stabilize the economy.
Anything as outlandish as a bridge to Cuba would be immediately shot down,
Gonzales explained, but he would make an effort to obtain funding for a
thorough survey of the Florida Strait, something that had been done only
partially in 1965. The survey could be played as an environmental move, thus
avoiding the taint of unnecessary spending and capitalizing on the
rapidly-growing environmental movement.
Gonzales's willingness to assist Aguero may seem strange on the surface. After
all, why would a successful U.S. Senator be so eager to assist a former Cuban
president trying to bring more tourists to his country, especially at the risk
of being labeled a "reckless spender?" Gonzales explained his reasoning in an
interview shortly before his death in 2004. "What they [the anti-tunnel
coalition] didn't understand was that these cars don't just appear from
nothing down there in Key West. They've got to drive in from out of state --
from New York, Michigan, whatever. And they're going to buy gas, buy
groceries, and maybe make a stop or two along the way. People who wouldn't
otherwise visit Florida would visit [us] on the way down to Cuba." In
addition, later questions were raised about whether Gonzales had been looking
for a "legacy project," something for people to remember him by in the history
books.
Regardless of his reasoning, one thing is certain -- after that May 1977
meeting, Gonzales became as firm a believer in the Key West-Havana tunnel as
Aguero himself. In late 1977, a provision in the Clean Water Act provided for
a $2 million study of the seabed of the Florida Strait. Though virtually no
Americans were aware of it, the U.S. government's involvement in the Florida
Strait Tunnel was officially under way.
That appropriation, of course, did little to alleviate the financial problems
troubling Aguero's underfunded group. Though the research would eventually
provide information critical to the planning of the tunnel, what was needed
immediately was funding to continue that planning. Through 1980, Aguero
continued to fund the small group out of his own pocket, but as he watched his
bank balance drop, he continued to petition the government for financial
support to no avail. In 1979, the Cuban media began to pick up on Aguero's
seemingly quixotic quest for a Florida Strait tunnel. His story was spread
across the country, and although most people considered his plan a crazy one,
his determination to see the plan through won him not a few supporters.
Private donations began trickling in from both Cubans and Americans who had
heard of his plan from newspapers in the United States.
As a result, in the fall of 1979, Aguero created the Florida Strait Tunnel
Company in order to appropriately manage the donations and whatever government
funding they would manage to gather in the future. For the first year of
operation, Aguero funded the company out of his own pocket and through
unsolicited donations. In the spring of 1980, two events would change all of
that.
The first of these was the announcement that Senator Gonzales had been named
the Republican vice-presidential candidate in the 1980 U.S. Presidential
Election. As a candidate, Gonzales served to balance the ticket of U.S.
Senator Ronald Reagan, who hailed from California. Running against incumbent
Democrat Jerry Brown, it was the first time that two politicians from the same
state had faced off for the Presidency. Aguero viewed the nomination as a
triumph for the tunnel project, but even if he could get elected, Gonzales
would face a tall task in forcing a tunnel funding bill through Congress. In
the United States, those people who had heard of Aguero's quest to build a
tunnel generally thought it to be a blue-sky project with no immediate chance
of coming true. A few far-sighted individuals did donate to Aguero's company,
but these were few and far between.
The second major event in the spring of 1980 to affect the tunnel plan would
change all of this. On February 8, 1980, the hydrofoil Barracuda caught fire
while traveling from Havana to Key West. Launched in the winter of 1979, the
Barracuda was considered the latest and greatest thing to come to the Havana
ferry route. Carrying 120 passengers, she could reach 45 knots and travel the
100 nautical miles between Key West and Havana in just over two hours, a vast
improvement over ships like the ill-fated Pride of Miami. The ancient LSTs had
long been phased out, but most of the car ferries on the route had more in
common with the Pride of Miami than they did with the modern Barracuda.
Tragically, the Barracuda's very modernness caused problems. New wiring aboard
the hydrofoil failed, sparking a fire fanned by the ship's rapid speed. By the
time the Barracuda was stopped, the flames were several hundred feet high,
tragically blocking the escape of many of the passengers.
Of the 134 passengers and crew, only 27 survived to be picked up by a U.S.
Coast Guard cutter responding to the ship's distress calls. The heat of the
fire was intense enough to melt the aluminum superstructure of the ship into a
blackened, twisted metal mess that hissed in a cloud of steam as it sank into
the ocean. Among the dead was New York Yankees pitcher Adiel Palma, a Cuban
national who had been returning to the United States prior to Spring Training.
Though not on the level of famed Yankees like Reggie Jackson, Bucky Dent, or
"Goose" Gossage, he nonetheless was intended to be an important part of the
Yankees pitching rotation heading into the 1980 season. His death, coming on
the heels of the plane-crash death of Thurman Munson, hit the Yankees hard.
In the United States at large, Palma's death put a face on the disaster for
the American public. While people may have had difficulty identifying with
faceless victims, they could certainly recognize the sorrow in the face of
Palma's widow. In the weeks following the disaster, Aguero traveled to the
United States making speeches proclaiming the need for a tunnel in order to
prevent tragedies like the Barracuda. Accusations that Aguero was capitalizing
on the deaths of others were put to rest when Palma's widow announced that she
would be making a large donation to Aguero's organization. In the wake of the
tragedy, the Cuban government, eager to show that it was doing something to
prevent further accidents, began subsidizing Aguero's corporation.
On the election trail, Senator Gonzales turned the accident into a campaign
issue when he made the announcement that he supported the construction of the
Key West-Havana tunnel at a stop in Texas. Ronald Reagan, having consulted
with Gonzales on the issue, also took up the tunnel's construction as part of
his "Rebuilding America" platform that targeted sitting president Jerry
Brown's failures in Iran, reviving the economy, and the fall of South Vietnam
to the North in 1978. Brown countered by attacking Reagan's age and accusing
him of being "fiscally reckless."
Despite Brown's counterattack, he could not shake his record of domestic and
international failure. Even his one international success -- the signing of
the START accords with the Soviet Union -- turned against him as Reagan was
able to cast Brown as "soft on Communism." Though that declaration carried
less of a sting than it did in the 1960s, thanks to the advent of denete, it
still hurt Brown in the South and Midwest. In part because of that loss,
Reagan and Gonzales won by an overwhelming margin in November. In March, 1981,
as part of Reagan's "Rebuilding America" campaign promise, negotiations began
between the United States and Cuba on a Tunnel Treaty.
As proposed, the treaty would outline the border issues associated with a
tunnel as well as detailing each nation's financial and jurisdictional
responsibilities during the construction. During the debates surrounding the
treaty in each country, the general public got its first look at the plans
proposed by Aguero's engineers. Until 1981, talk about the tunnel had been
couched in the most general of terms. Engineers hired by the major television
networks could only speculate about the exact specifications, and so debate
was generally limited by what was known. When more precise data was released
that spring, debate over the tunnel exploded. Every special-interest group
from the environmental movement to trade groups to manufacturing concerns
wanted to make their voice heard, and wanted their chance to speak -- now.
In the United States, environmental groups were appalled by the tunnel's path
through the coral reef off Key West. As planned, the tunnel would have been
blasted through the reef before reaching deeper water, causing immense damage
to the delicate ecosystem. In regards to trade, American unions feared that
the tunnel would allow a flood of low-cost Cuban products to enter the
country, thanks to Cuba's lower minimum wage. These were the sorts of problems
that faced the Tunnel Treaty negotiations. Dozens of groups demanded -- and
got -- their say, forcing changes in the name of political compromise.
The plan to have the tunnel run along the seafloor in shallower water was
shelved at the behest of the environmental lobby. Instead, the tunnel would go
below the reef south of Key West, dug through the dead, bleached segments of
the reef a hundred feet below the reef's living heart. It was a compromise
that left no one happy, least of all the companies planning on bidding to
build the tunnel, for whom the cost of construction climbed with every
concession. The labor unions got their bone as well, with Reagan's pledge that
no free-trade agreement would be signed with Cuba for at least thirty years.
That promise was written into the treaty as well. The negotiations in
committee lasted for several months, and with each passing day, Andres Rivero
Aguero, president of the Florida Strait Tunnel Company, feared that he would
never see his tunnel built.
In 1981, Aguero celebrated his 76th birthday, and despite his advanced age, he
was remarkably spry and active, often spending twelve hours a day working in
the Company's growing Havana offices or making speeches in support of the
tunnel's construction. These speeches smoothed the way for the passage of the
Tunnel Treaty in Cuba, where Aguero, despite his past as a backer of Batista,
had become greatly popular among Cuba's new generation of middle-class
workers. These were men and women who had grown up entirely under a democratic
government, and for whom "Batista" was merely a name in the history books, one
their parents discussed in the same way they talked about walking to school.
To them, Aguero and the tunnel became a symbol of the new Cuba, a country
equal to or even greater than their neighbor to the north, the United States.
To their parents, the United States had always been "the boss," home of the
tourists who supported the Cuban economy. For the new generation, the United
States was a "brother," home to branches of Cuban corporations, the place
where many Cubans went to be educated, and merely another country, with no
negative connotation.
This trend only would become apparent well after Aguero's death in 1997, but
throughout the 1980s, he became its beneficiary. As more and more Cubans of
the new generation became eligible to vote (the legal voting age had been
lowered to 18 in 1975), they put more and more pro-tunnel legislators into
office. These politicians saw an advantage in the tunnel's construction, and
they would prove to be some of Aguero's strongest supporters when the tunnel's
fate seemed uncertain.
In the United States, however, there was none of this emotion. That country,
still recovering from the political and economic setbacks of the 1970s,
largely viewed the tunnel as a needless expense, Reagan and Gonzales's claims
of "Rebuilding America" aside. In order to get the political backing necessary
for the approval of the Tunnel Treaty, several compromises had to be made. The
most important of these was the requirement that all pieces of the tunnel had
to be manufactured in the United States. This was done to contest the idea put
forth by tunnel opponents that Cuba would be benefiting more from the
construction costs than the United States. Furthermore, several factories in
politically important states were recommended to manufacture tunnel sections
and components. To assuage Cuban protests, additional clauses required 75% of
the ships used in the construction of the tunnel to be Cuban-flagged and
required 60% of the personnel working on the project to be hired in Cuba.
These and other negotiations went slowly, and it wasn't until November 1981
that the treaty was submitted to the Senate for ratification. On November 16,
1981, the 97th U.S. Congress, by a narrow margin, voted to grant its advice
and consent on the subject of the Cuban-American Tunnel Treaty. A beaming Vice
President Gonzales presided over the vote in his ceremonial position. American
newspapers hailed "the father of the tunnel," as he was called. The Cuban view
that Aguero was the true "father" of the tunnel was not widely considered.
That minor controversy was smoothed over by the approval of the Tunnel Treaty.
In a Thanksgiving Day ceremony, President Reagan and the President of Cuba
signed the treaty into law for both countries. In attendance were Vice
President Gonzales, Andres Aguero, and representatives from virtually every
major construction company in the world. Almost everyone present had immense
interest in the next phase of the tunnel project -- the bid for the contract
to build the tunnel. The potential rewards were immense, but so were the
risks. The winning bidder would receive a 60-year monopoly on tunnel
construction across the Florida Strait, a boon potentially worth billions of
dollars. But in order to receive that boon, the bidder first had to jump the
hurdles of fundraising and building the tunnel, and these obstacles seemed
immense, even to the world's largest construction and investment companies.
Three months after the signing of the Tunnel Treaty, a request for bids and
proposals was submitted by the Joint American Tunnel Administration Commission
(JATAC). Potential bidders would have 18 months from the date of the request
(February 27, 1982) to submit their sealed bid proposals to the Commission. In
that time, prospective bidders would have to gather information, create a
rough plan of construction, and find financing. The size of the project was
immense. Media commentators compared the scale of the problem to that facing
the builders of the Suez Canal, the builders of the Pyramids, or any number of
other great construction projects throughout history. They were always quick
to point out, however, that none of the projects -- with the exception of the
Great Wall of China -- approached the size of the planned tunnel and that this
would be the second-largest single human-built object in history.
Many comparisons were made to the Seikan Tunnel project, which was about to
break ground in Japan with the goal of connecting the Home Islands of Honshu
and Hokkaido. Even more comparisons were drawn to the long-imagined Channel
Tunnel in Europe. That tunnel was still in the distant planning stages after
having been cancelled in the mid-1970s as a result of Prime Minister Harold
Wilson's cost-cutting. Thanks to the publicity surrounding the Florida Strait
Tunnel, that formerly moribund project had begun to gain steam once more, and
Britain and France were talking about a Channel Tunnel Treaty along the lines
of the Cuban-American treaty. But both the Seikan and Chunnel were still far
from reality and each plan was still less than a third of the length of even
the shortest potential Florida Strait Tunnel.
Estimates of the total cost of the project ranged from a conservative $10
billion to a monstrous $60 billion. According to the Tunnel Treaty, one-third
of the cost of construction would be paid by each contributor to the project:
the builder, the American government, and the Cuban government. Both the
American and Cuban contributions, however, would take the form of
interest-free loans to the tunnel builder, to be repaid by the end of the
60-year monopoly period. This 2/3 contribution by the two governments would
only count for the first $50 billion of costs. Anything beyond this
wallet-smashing cost would have to be borne by private investors, who would
also contribute the remaining third of the project's bill.
Initially, three corporations received the bulk of the media coverage
surrounding the "race for the Tunnel," as it was termed in the national media
of both Cuba and the United States. The fact that it was in no way a race was
conveniently overlooked in the competitive spirit. The company perceived most
likely to "win the race" was American construction and energy conglomerate
Bechtel, which had performed extensive private surveying of the Florida Strait
beyond that provided in the 1978 U.S. Government survey and other minor
surveys conducted since. In addition, Bechtel embarked on an extensive public
relations campaign to convince the public that it could provide a "permanent,
quality link between the United States and Cuba."
The corporation seen as Bechtel's primary competitor in the "race" was the
American Bridge Company, of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Founded in 1900, the ABC
had, by 1982, been involved in most of the biggest transportation construction
projects in the United States during the last half of the 20th Century. While
rival Bechtel could claim a history as a prime contractor for the Hoover Dam
-- President Reagan's favorite metaphor for the building of the tunnel --
American Bridge could proudly proclaim New York's Verrazano-Narrows Bridge,
the Orinoco Bridge in Venezuela, the Sears Tower, the Boeing 747 Assembly
Building, and the Louisiana Superdome among its accomplishments. Insiders
privately considered American Bridge to be the front-runner in the
competition. After all, it already had extensive experience building large
infrastructure projects, many of them in deep water. For the construction of
the Florida Strait Tunnel, American Bridge promised to bring in miniature
submarines with the capability of descending to the bottom of the mile-deep
strait.
The third corporation to receive a great deal of media coverage during the 18
months of the bidding process was not widely considered to be a front-runner.
Thanks to the reputation of Andres Aguero, however, the Florida Strait Tunnel
Company was never far from the minds of those who followed the progress of the
tunnel project. In Cuba, Aguero was hailed as a national hero and covered as
such in the national media. His reputation barely mentioned a sentence in most
American newspapers covering the tunnel-building project. In Cuba, Aguero was
a masterful fundraiser, gathering promises of loans fro Cuban banks totaling
over $3 billion in the first month following the bid announcement. However, in
the United States, Aguero was stonewalled. Almost no American bank would give
an ear to the strange man from Cuba who tried to get them to pledge immense
sums of money to a wild project.
Investors' skepticism was perhaps well-founded. Of the 17 companies that would
eventually submit bids for the project, the Florida Strait Tunnel Company was
by far the smallest. While Bechtel could boast over 30,000 employees
worldwide, and American Bridge could list over 10,000 American employees, the
Tunnel Company employed fewer than 100 people at the time of the request for
bids in February 1982. As to sales -- it had none. What little operating
capital it enjoyed was courtesy of donations from tunnel supporters and the
sale of company shares in late 1981. With those limited funds, Florida Tunnel
struggled to design and raise the money for the world's largest construction
project.
The stress of Florida Tunnel's uphill struggle took its toll on the
78-year-old Aguero. Stonewalled by American investors, in six months he
managed to extract promises of only $500 million from various banks and
investment groups. In Cuba over the same period, he managed to get pledges of
a billion additional dollars. But the Cuban well was running dry. As
successful as Aguero had been in getting loans from Cuban banks, there were
only so many banks with the willingness and capability to provide the
multi-million-dollar promises that were needed to finance the tunnel. The
economic resources of Cuba, no matter how deeply they were tapped, simply
couldn't match those of even a small fraction of what the United States could
bring to bear in terms of investment. In December 1982, the fundraising trail
struck down Aguero. Admitted to Hospital Clínico Quirúrgico with sharp stomach
pain, Aguero was diagnosed with stress-induced bleeding ulcers. With less than
eight months remaining to complete a bid proposal, the hopes of the Florida
Strait Tunnel Company appeared to be sunk.
Aguero had been the company's most prominent member and most capable
fundraiser. With the announcement that he would be confined to bed for several
months, several investors withdrew their pledges of support. New investors
were hard to come by, particularly with the widespread coverage the Cuban
media gave to Aguero's illness. As 1982 turned into 1983, Aguero was receiving
daily blood transfusions to replace what was lost through his bleeding ulcers.
At its darkest hour, and thanks to investors dropping their promises, the
Florida Strait Tunnel Company had barely one week's operating capital
remaining when help arrived from an unlikely source. As Aguero lay
recuperating in his hospital bed, he was visited by representatives from the
American Bridge Company. With them, they brought an unexpected offer -- a
merger.
The two dark-suited Americans that visited laid out their proposal: In
exchange for selling their shares in the Florida Strait Tunnel Company,
shareholders would receive a portion of the profits of the completed tunnel.
American Bridge would gain access to the extensive research and planning done
by the Tunnel Company as well absorbing the Company's experienced stable of
engineers, including Alan Grant, the engineer who had first proposed the
tunnel design, and Aguero's two Cuban engineers, the longest-serving members
of the Company other than Aguero himself. As part of the deal, Aguero would be
named the chairman of the project, bringing his immense prestige in Cuba to
the service of American Bridge, which, while successful in gaining backers in
the United States, had thus far been unsuccessful in attracting Cuban interest
in its plan. Aguero, wheelchair-bound due to weakness from blood loss,
contemplated the matter for five minutes. Then he turned down the two men
cold. He had not spent half his lifetime working on the tunnel, not seen it
through the dark hours, to now sell his plan to a bunch of Yanqui
industrialists. No. He would go down fighting, if he had to go down at all. It
was his dream, and he was in charge of it. No one else.
Having met a roadblock in the form of Aguero, American Bridge tried an end run
around him. They spoke with Alan Grant, then Aguero's two original engineers.
They talked with the Florida Strait Tunnel Company's backers, and to the
company's other employees. But it all boiled down to Aguero himself. He had
kept enough of the company's shares to block any potential move in favor of a
merger, and so he had to be in favor of the move or it would not happen. For
three weeks, representatives from American Bridge, Alan Grant, and what seemed
like every employee the Tunnel Company had cycled through Aguero's hospital
room in an effort to convince him to change his mind, but he would not budge.
In desperation, Grant called Vice President Gonzales in Washington. Gonzales
flew to Havana, ostensibly on a friendly visit to Cuba. In a meeting together
with Grant and Aguero's two engineers, they forced Aguero to see the truth. He
had been away from the company for too long, had not seen the money slowly
running out despite pledges of billion-dollar loans, pledges that could not be
collected unless the company won the tunnel contract. Only when Grant showed
him the red-lined balance sheets did Aguero change his mind and agree to
American Bridge's purchase of his company. "So this is the end?" he reportedly
asked Gonzales. "No, my friend, it is the beginning." Gonzales replied. And so
it was.
On September 1, 1983, 17 companies turned in sealed envelopes to the Joint
American Tunnel Administration Commission. Over the next week, the six members
of the Commission (3 American and 3 Cuban) examined each proposal and bid for
feasibility and adherence to the bid regulations. Though the lowest bid would
ordinarily be accepted, if a proposal bypassed any of the major requirements,
it would be rejected even if the bid was low. The bidding process received a
shock of attention on the fourth day of deliberations when British
construction company Balfour Beatty announced that it would be withdrawing its
bid in an effort to concentrate on the planned Channel Tunnel, which had just
been declared a major priority of the British government. Following the
withdrawal of Balfour Beatty, which had been considered one of the likely
winners of the bidding process, the tunnel returned again to the headlines.
After 18 months of behind-the-scenes planning, the tunnel had faded from the
media's attention. Engineering diagrams and budget negotiations, no matter how
fascinating they might have been to the people involved, simply didn't
generate interesting stories.
For the last three days of deliberations, media commentators speculated wildly
about who might emerge with the single largest non-military government
contract since the creation of the Interstate System. Would it be Bechtel, the
industry giant? Could a resurgent American Bridge group emerge the victor? Or
would one of the 14 remaining underdog candidates come up with the lowest bid?
On September 8, North America had its answer. With a bid of $37.4 billion, the
American Bridge Company was awarded the contract to build the Florida Strait
tunnel.
Coming in second was Bechtel, with a bid of $49.3 billion. Other companies'
bids were above the $50 billion mark, thanks in part to the need to build the
companies' infrastructure before even starting construction. In the years that
followed, multiple accusations of corporate espionage, vote-rigging, and other
underhanded tactics were levied against American Bridge. Nothing was ever
proven, and several libel lawsuits on behalf of the company put an end to many
of the accusations. Ironically, it was later revealed that Balfour Beatty had
entered a bid below that of American Bridge, and had the bid been upheld, a
British company would have been the builder of the Florida Strait Tunnel
connecting the United States to Cuba.
With the contracts signed and American Bridge having ended the anticipation
over the picking of a contractor, the tunnel project once again returned to
obscurity, at least as far as the newspaper front pages were concerned. For
the engineers and employees of the American Bridge Corporation, the real work
had only just begun. With Andres Aguero only barely back on his feet from his
prolonged hospital stay and still learning the ropes in his position as the
official chairman of American Bridge's tunnel group, much of the work was
shouldered by his assistants. The tunnel group was the portion of American
Bridge devoted to the Florida Strait Tunnel, and as the project grew in
complexity, it had grown in proportion. By the time news of the successful bid
reached American Bridge's headquarters in Pittsburgh, virtually every person
employed by the company was also a member of the tunnel group. To ease
coordination, American bridge opened offices in Key West, Miami, Havana, and
Hershey, Cuba, which was to be the site of the Cuba end of the tunnel.
Even as orders for equipment and supplies were placed from these offices, the
tunnel's design continued to change. American Bridge engineers had initially
designed the tunnel as an automobile route carrying four lanes of divided
traffic beneath the Florida Strait. It was a design that followed those of
other American Bridge projects, and reflected the American company's history
building road networks. A road tunnel had several problems when applied to the
enormous distance of the Florida Strait, however, problems that could only be
resolved with expensive solutions. The first problem to be addressed was that
of ventilation. Four lanes of automobile traffic would generate an immense
amount of exhaust, and that would have to be removed lest the tunnel turn into
a 90-mile-long gas chamber before the first car crossed. The solution American
Bridge engineers came up with involved a series of 30 enormous ventilators
tied to buoyant, floating exhaust stacks. The fact that these would be
hideously vulnerable to hurricanes or other storms was ignored in the haste to
get a plan ready. In addition, the simple mechanics of operating a 90-mile
highway would also have to be dealt with. How would the tunnel handle car
accidents at the halfway point? What would happen when a car ran out of gas?
These and other problems multiplied exponentially, helping lead to American
Bridge's decision to acquire the Florida Strait Tunnel Company, which had
managed to come up with a solution -- not using cars at all. Instead, the
Tunnel Company's design used a train shuttle service, thus avoiding all the
problems of automobile exhaust, cars breaking down, and human error. To be
sure, the train design would require the construction of two massive
terminals, creating a whole new set of problems in the land-starved Florida
Keys, home of the northern end of the tunnel. But the Tunnel Company had a
solution for that problem as well. The U.S. Navy had announced in 1980 that it
would be closing its naval air station on the island of Boca Chica. The island
would be a perfect location for a terminal -- if the land could be acquired
before news of the company's interest blew prices sky-high.
By the time of American Bridge's winning bid, the Tunnel Company design had
won out over the auto tunnel put forth by American Bridge's own designers,
thus enabling the company to turn in the winning bid. But there had not been
enough time to finalize the design, and so throughout the last three months of
1983, in drafting rooms in Pittsburgh and Miami engineers labored to complete
the design first imagined by Alan Grant nearly a decade previously. Though the
details still were not known, initial work continued. In November 1983, the
U.S. Navy held a public auction for its Boca Chica property. Only the portion
of the base south of U.S. 1 was for sale, but this was the exact portion
required for the envisioned terminal. Through third parties and secret
intermediaries, American bridge sent representatives to participate in the
auction for the property. Though successful, they paid a high price for the
terminal's eventual location -- $47 million. Several developers had had their
eyes on the island as a potential resort destination along the route of the
eventual undersea railroad, and only the deep pockets of American Bridge
allowed it to eventually triumph. Though the company attempted to keep its
purchase a secret, word eventually leaked out via a story in a local
newspaper, causing a massive spike in property values throughout the Lower
Keys.
The purchasing of land for the Cuba end of the tunnel was a far smoother
process. The town of Hershey, Cuba had earned its unique name as the
headquarters of the Hershey Chocolate Company's cocoa plantations in Cuba. A
massive rail network had been laid through the town, and cocoa packaging
plants still dotted the landscape, though many laid dormant at the time of the
tunnel's arrival, courtesy of the Hershey company's sale of the plantation in
1948. The site of the Cuban terminal as well as ample land for employee
housing was purchased for a paltry $1.5 million. The residents of the small
town were only too happy to welcome American Bridge representatives, who they
hoped would revitalize their small town, largely bypassed by the casino and
tourist economic explosion of the 1960s and 1970s. As in the Keys, land values
in and around Hershey rose dramatically after the purchase, but unlike in the
Keys, the spike was limited by the amount of land available.
At sea, American Bridge began assembling a massive construction fleet. Most of
the ships, as required by the JATAC, were Cuban-flagged vessels hired from
Havana, Guantanamo, or any of a number of Cuban ports. These would not just be
needed to lay tunnel segments and set concrete weights, but also to supply the
vessels that would be doing those very things. The centerpiece of the flotilla
was none other than the infamous Glomar Explorer, built by Hughes Aerospace at
the behest of the Central Intelligence Agency in order to recover a sunken
Soviet missile submarine. In the wake of that mission's failure and subsequent
revelation by the Los Angeles Times, the ship had been mothballed by the U.S.
Navy and kept in its Suisun Bay Reserve Fleet. Purchased by American Bridge in
October, 1983, the ship immediately entered drydock for extensive
modifications in order to better serve its new role positioning and
manipulating the enormous steel tubes that would make up the tunnel. Though
the ship came cheap -- only $10 million from a government eager to offload the
ship, the modifications and upgrades were to cost more than $75 million.
This massive expense was still a minor cost when compared to the complete cost
of the project, however. In order to fulfill the total bid of $37.4 billion,
American Bridge and Andres Aguero had to negotiate a labyrinth of contracts
and requirements. Just over one-third of that total -- $12.7 billion -- had
been loaned by a consortium of banks, private investors, and private
individuals. This was the starting capital for the project, and as soon as the
bid was accepted and the contract signed by the JATAC and American Bridge, the
timer started ticking on the tunnel project. For every day that construction
was delayed, the cost in owed interest and lost revenue would amount to over
$1 million. The much-touted interest-free government loans, which had been the
center of opposition to the tunnel project as an example of profligate
government spending, would not come into play until certain benchmarks in the
tunnel construction had been met. Much like the plan that had financed the
United States' first transcontinental railroad, American Bridge would receive
a set amount in interest-free loans for every mile of tunnel completed. For
the first 50 miles south from Boca Chica, U.S.-backed loans would be issued.
For the first 50 miles north from Hershey, Cuban-backed loans would be issued.
But until a design was finalized, no manufacturing of tunnel segments could
begin, no portions of tunnel could be completed, and no government loans could
be collected.
On January 23, 1984, the first of those roadblocks was removed with the
freezing of the tunnel design. The tunnel itself was deceptively simple in
design. Of course, the devil was in the details. Each 200-foot tunnel section
consists of several parts. The first of these was the outer hull, designed to
be water-tight and strong enough to resist the water pressure at 95 feet (the
tunnel's depth below sea level). Functioning exactly like the outer pressure
hull on a submarine, each section contains ballast tanks, two railroad tubes,
a maintenance tube, and multiple pumps and cable and pipe lines. The ballast
tanks, located between the outer tunnel and the railroad tubes, are the most
critical portion of each tunnel segment. They provide the buoyancy that keeps
the tunnel from sinking to the bottom of the Strait, and keep it held tight by
the stabilizing cables. Contrary to popular belief, the tunnel is not held up
by the cables, but by the buoyancy provided by the ballast tanks.
A pump is located in each of the 8 separate tanks in each tunnel section. They
take up the entire inner surface of the outer shell of the tunnel, and in
effect create the inner hull of the tunnel shell. Each of the tanks can be
flooded or emptied as needed, but most are typically kept empty in order to
maximize the amount of buoyancy. The tanks at the bottom of the tunnel shell
are an exception to this rule, as they are usually partially filled in order
to provide stability for the tunnel and minimize the tunnel shell's tendency
to roll when not weighted properly. The only time the ballast tanks were fully
flooded was during the emplacement process, when the sections' normal buoyancy
had to be overcome in order to place them at the proper depth. Once placed,
welded to existing sections, and connected to the cable and weight system, the
ballast tanks would be fully vented for normal operation.
Within the inner hull formed by the ballast tanks are the three transportation
tubes. Electrified railroad tracks run through the two largest tubes, which
are connected to the tunnel shell by a series of shock absorbers designed to
minimize the stresses on the tunnel shell and the welds connecting tunnel
sections. Spaced regularly along the tunnel are crossover pipes, which connect
the two railroad tubes and relieve the air pressure trains generate as they
travel through the tunnel. As trains travel through the tunnel, there is
insufficient room in the confines of the railroad tubes for air to get around
the rapidly-moving trains, and so the crossover pipes are needed to relieve
this air pressure before it causes damage to the train or railroad tube.
Between the two railroad tubes is the maintenance tube, which is kept at a
higher pressure than the rest of the tunnel in order to provide a refuge area
in the event of major problems. Regularly-spaced pressure doors provide easy
access to the two railroad tubes and the air spaces between the tunnel shell
and transportation tubes. These air spaces are inspected regularly for leaks
and provide access to the electrical cables, pumps, and everything else
critical to the operation of the tunnel. Unlike the two railroad tubes, no
tracks run through the maintenance tube. Tunnel employees instead use
specially-designed electric cars to travel throughout the 90-mile length of
the maintenance tube.
Also included in the 98-mile length of the tunnel are six switching points,
which allow trains to cross from one train tube to the other in the event that
a section of track needs to be shut down for maintenance. They are spaced
evenly -- one for every 15 miles of track -- and are some of the largest
wholly-underwater structures in the world. Each is approximately twice the
size of a normal tunnel section, and this fact caused no shortage of
difficulties during the emplacement process.
Over 2,300 regular sections would be needed to complete the tunnel, and even
if something went wrong with any individual tunnel section, the design was
redundant enough to compensate. Should a tunnel segment suffer a leak and be
completely filled with water, the ballast tanks would continue to provide more
than enough buoyancy to remain in place. If the buoyancy tanks were ruptured,
the tunnel section would still be supported by other tunnel sections nearby.
According to the design, every ballast tank in five consecutive sections would
need to be ruptured in order to create enough negative buoyancy to cause
damage to the tunnel. However, an event that could cause damage that extensive
would likely destroy those portions of the tunnel entirely.
In the March, 1984 issue of Popular Mechanics, the tunnel design was hailed as
the greatest engineering breakthrough since the Pyramids. The claim was
repeated by other trade publications and was even taken up by President Reagan
in his campaign for re-election. It was a claim that Gary Hart, the Democratic
candidate for President, found impossible to match. Reagan's economic plans,
though criticized for the amount of money they spent, were largely successful
in establishing a rapid recovery for the national economy. Hart found an
easier target in Reagan's military policy, which he criticized for being
overly antagonistic and reversing the denete that had begun with Kennedy and
resulted in multiple agreements limiting the nuclear arms race.
But for the workers of American Bridge and for the members of JATAC, the
events surrounding the American presidential campaign faded into the
background as work on the tunnel went forward. In April, Andres Augero made
the biggest decision of his still-young career as head of American Bridge's
tunnel department as he signed contracts with the subcontractors who would be
building the tunnel shells. The decision was enormous in both financial and
physical terms -- the tunnel shells would constitute the largest and most
visible portion of the project, and would consist of 3/5 of the total cost of
the project. The problems involved with such a large series of subcontracts
were exacerbated by competition from President Reagan's military buildup,
which included the construction of two new classes of submarines -- the
Ohio-class ballistic missile submarine, and the Los Angeles-class attack
submarine. As tunnel sections were extremely similar in structure to
submarines, throughout the 1970s it had been thought that the construction of
tunnel sections could easily be done at shipyards in Connecticut, Virginia,
and California. But by 1984, the shipyards that had lain dormant throughout
the 1970s were flush with new orders from the U.S. Navy.
Due to that fact, American Bridge was forced to sign contracts with shipyards
in places like Evansville, Indiana, Seattle, Washington, and Bangor, Maine.
Places that had never seen a submarine before now found themselves building
dozens of hollow tunnel sections. This forced American Bridge to pay higher
prices, due to the expense involved in transporting the sections down the
Atlantic coast, through the Panama Canal, or down the Mississippi River. It
also forced Aguero to sign contracts with less-than-reputable contractors.
This resulted in several tunnel sections being built to unsafe standards. One
contractor in New Orleans was later accused of massive design violations and
cutting corners in order to save money. By 1992, no fewer than 24 sections had
to be physically cut out from already-finished portions of the tunnel and
replaced at massive expense. The resulting lawsuit cost the subcontractor
several hundred million dollars in damages, eventually forcing the company
into bankruptcy.
These were isolated incidents, however. Fewer than one percent of the tunnel
segments were voided due to cause, a remarkable percentage considering the
number of subcontractors, tunnel segments, and the extremely difficult
circumstances under which they were built and put into place. But that was in
the future -- in April, 1984, the delivery of the first section was still
eight months away. Until that time, there were more than enough problems to go
around.
The first of these was the preparation of the sites in Hershey and Boca Chica
Key. Vertical shafts were drilled down 150 through rock-hard coral and
sediment scarcely thicker than the water that would support the tunnel shells.
Coral dust proved to be spectacularly erosive, destroying drill bits that
should have lasted 500 feet in only 50. Tunnel Boring Machines, like those
being used for the Seikan tunnel in Japan and planned for the Channel Tunnel
in Europe, were off limits due to the unstable ground. At Boca Chica, coral
could give way to pockets of water-filled sediment without warning, and the
problem would only grow worse once the shafts were completed and the drillers
began working towards the sea. To avoid the inevitable flooding that would
take place when the tunnelers reached the ocean, giant end-caps were dropped
into place at the approximate spots where the tunnels would reach the sea and
switch to the free-floating tunnel segments. Constructed of the first two
completed tunnel segments, the caps were dropped to the appropriate depths and
pushed into the sediment. Divers were then sent down to dig forward until
reaching coral. A water-tight seal could then be formed between the caps and
the rock. After that, it was a matter of merely constructing a water-tight
connection between the shaft and the end cap. The entire process would not be
complete until June 1988, by which time plenty of free-floating tunnel
sections were available to connect to the excavated portions.
In the meantime, American Tunnel's efforts at sea were focused on preparing
the concrete seabed counterweights and steel cables that would restrain the
buoyant tunnel sections. Left free to float, the tunnel sections would rise to
the surface, vulnerable to the elements and blocking shipping traffic through
the Florida Strait. To counteract the designed buoyancy of the tunnel
sections, each was designed to be attached to a series of concrete weights
connected to the tunnel by a steel-cable cradle. Beginning in May, 1984, the
first concrete blocks began to arrive in Miami. As they weighed in at 20 tons
apiece, positioning the weights was no small task, especially considering that
most would need to be positioned at a depth of 4,000 feet or more. The
flexibility of the steel cables used meant that the weights did not need to be
placed with enormous precision, but though the tunnel workers were spared that
difficulty, an enormous task still faced them. It was the equivalent of
lowering a car through a pea-soup fog from a helicopter hovering at a height
twice that of the Sears Tower and placing it in a single parking spot.
In the planning stages, American Bridge engineers had suggested the use of
miniature submersibles, such as the Deep Submergence Vehicle Alvin,
commissioned by the U.S. Navy in 1964 and operated by the Woods Hole
Oceanographic Institute in Massachusetts. In trials, however, the minisubs
proved to lack the engine power and cargo capacity to reliably transport and
manipulate the 20-ton concrete blocks. Even the nuclear-powered NR-1, had it
been available, lacked the need power and the deep-diving capability to reach
the deeper portions of the tunnel route. With minisubs not an option, Aguero
was forced to approve more traditional methods of deep-water construction.
With the Glomar Explorer in dry dock until 1985, the interim tunnel-laying
ship Christopher Columbus was pressed into service placing the concrete
weights.
The Columbus, a converted freighter modified in a Cuban shipyard by American
Bridge to work on the tunnel project, had originally been intended to serve as
the Glomar Explorer's counterpart at sea, laying tunnel sections from the
Cuban coast northward while the Explorer worked from Boca Chica southward.
However, the delays in finalizing the tunnel design and creating the tunnel
sections, coupled with the Explorer's longer-than-expected stay in dry dock
meant the Columbus's crew cooled their heels in Havana as the days passed.
Ordered to Miami in June, the crew of the Columbus found an ample stack of
concrete weights awaiting them in the Port of Miami. After taking the weights
aboard, the ship set sail for a position just south of Sand Key, the point
where the tunnel's hundred-foot depth would emerge into open water after
digging below the reef south of Key West. The work progressed surprisingly
well for the crew of the Columbus, and they were able to lay several dozen
weights per day with remarkable accuracy after the normal difficulties
associated with a new job.
As the ocean floor began to drop off and the waters of the Florida Strait
deepened, however, the rate of progress slowed to a crawl. Where the Columbus
had been able to lay up to 100 weights per day in shallower water, the deeper
portions of the Strait challenged the Columbus's crane operators and riggers.
The Strait's currents, coupled with the growing distance between the Columbus
and the seafloor meant that any error was magnified as the water became
deeper. With four weights needed for each of the tunnel's 2,369 tunnel
sections, even a short delay in the process would be magnified by the number
of times it needed to be repeated. By the beginning of 1985, the Columbus was
barely managing to correctly place a single weight daily.
The solution to this problem came when planners reexamined the original
strategy of laying the weights with minisubs. Though those vehicles still
lacked the capability to transport the weights by themselves, the minisubs
could still manipulate the weights into a more precise position than the
Columbus could on its own. In the spring of 1985, American Tunnel began to
lease a pair of minisubs for work on the tunnel project. As the Columbus
lowered each weight several thousand feet to the bottom of the Florida Strait,
a minisub would be at the bottom, guiding it into place and counteracting the
effect of currents and other problems that might arise during the trip to the
seafloor. By providing a pair (or several) of human eyes on the seafloor,
American Tunnel also avoided several problems that had arisen or would arise
during the tunnel's construction.
By using a minisub, American Tunnel surveyors could avoid problems associated
with seafloor obstructions and obstacles, such as boulders. In one notable
incident, the Sea Cliff, one of the four different subs hired by the company,
discovered several WWII-era munitions, probably dumped by the U.S. Navy,
directly in the projected path of the tunnel route. After consulting the Navy,
the decision was made to dispose of the munitions via explosives. In other
instances, the minisubs discovered seafloor obstacles like boulder fields or
terrain changes that the sonar surveys or underwater cameras had not been able
to distinguish. By using the Sea Cliff and other submarines to maneuver the
weights around these obstacles, valuable time was saved and the pace of
construction greatly increased. By late 1985, the Columbus was laying concrete
weights at a vastly increased speed. By the fall of 1988, all 9,476 weights
along the entire 90-mile length of submarine tunnel were in place and the
Columbus had been reassigned to its originally-designed purpose -- laying
tunnel sections.
The introduction of minisubs on the tunnel project also had effects beyond the
tunnel project. From the late 1980s through the mid-90s, the United States
experienced an explosion in popular interest in submarines and undersea
exploration. The beginnings of minisub involvement on the tunnel project
greatly effected Dr. Robert Ballard's search for and discovery of the wreck of
the Titanic in 1986, and assisted the growth of treasure hunting and the
search for shipwrecks. In popular media, the discovery of the Titanic and the
work on the tunnel inspired television shows such as SeaQuest and the new
Flipper series. Minisubs would continue to be involved in the project through
its completion, having been reassigned to cable work following the completion
of the laying of the weights. Even today, submarines prove to be a crucial
part of the tunnel maintenance process, inspecting and repairing portions of
steel cable far beyond the reach of surface-based divers. In 2002, the Tunnel
Authority went so far as to purchase outright the Habana, a 50-foot minisub
capable of reaching every portion of the Florida Strait's depths and assigned
to observe and maintain the tunnel as needed.
The main duty of the Habana is to keep an eye on the miles of steel cables
that restrain the tunnel and keep it from floating to the surface. Because
they are perpetually immersed in seawater, they are extremely vulnerable to
corrosion, and must be repeatedly monitored and maintained as needed. As with
the building of the tunnel shells, the steel cables had to be manufactured at
several locations across the United States. According to the design, each
tunnel section was restrained four times, connected by cable to the concrete
weights laid by the Christopher Columbus. The cables connect to the sections
at the "corners," so much as a ovoid cylinder can be said to have corners.
With nearly 9,500 weights connecting to approximately 2,400 tunnel sections,
an immense amount of cable had to be created. Nearly 10,000 miles of it, in
fact.
Steel cable wasn't a new invention by any means, nor was it new to the
engineers of American Bridge. They had planned and built the Verrazano-Narrows
Bridge in New York City, which was the world's longest suspension bridge until
surpassed by the Humber Bridge in Britain in 1981. The Verrazano-Narrows
Bridge used over 143,000 miles of steel wire over its mile-long spans, and the
construction of the Florida Strait Tunnel would surpass even this enormous
amount by a fair margin.
To create steel cable, strands of steel wire are repeatedly wound to create
small cables. These cables are then bundled together to create larger cables,
and so forth. The whole assembly is then usually shrouded in a cylindrical
housing in order to reduce corrosion. The technique was created in Germany
during the 1830s and used in bridges and construction in the United States
since the creation of the Brooklyn Bridge. American Bridge engineers were
extremely familiar with steel cable's flexibility and strength, and planned
from the beginning to incorporate it into the design. There were two problems
with the use of steel cable in the tunnel, however: scale and corrosion.
The scale of the project meant that over 38 million miles of steel wire would
be needed to complete the cable girdles restraining the 90-mile length of the
tunnel. 5,000 individual strands of wire would compose each cable, meaning
that as the tunnel crossed the deepest portions of the Strait, a single tunnel
section would be attached to over 20,000 miles of wire -- one-seventh as much
as used in the entire Verrazano-Narrows project. Engineers would later compare
this manufacturing process to those that manufactured the Apollo spacecraft
and the Freedom Space Station. From the time the first orders were placed in
July 1984, the steel cable-manufacturing facility of American Cable and Wire
in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, went on a full three-shift non-stop manufacturing
schedule. It would not stop operating this schedule for 11 years.
The situation was similar at forges across the midwest. In places like Gary,
Indiana, and Toledo, Ohio, wire and cable manufacturers received contracts and
subcontracts that would sustain them for a full decade. To meet the demand in
raw steel, companies like U.S. Steel received orders for tons of raw material.
Historians today credit much of the survival of America's steel industry to
the flood of orders that resulted from the demand for millions of miles of
steel wire. The money companies like U.S. Steel made on the orders for the
Florida Strait Tunnel allowed them to modernize and compete with the Asian and
European steel companies that had taken over the demand for automobile steel.
The problem of corrosion was almost as enormous as the problems of
manufacturing so much steel wire. The cables restraining the tunnel would be
immersed in some of the most corrosive fluid known to man -- oxygen-rich salt
water. One weak spot in the anti-corrosion coating applied to each bit of
steel wire could cause the wire to rust and break. One wire breaking could
cause a cable to fail and weaken the overall structure of the tunnel. One
cable in and of itself couldn't cause damage to the tunnel, nor would several
failing in succession. Every cable on five consecutive tunnel sections would
have to fail before the buoyancy of the sections would begin to crack the
welds holding them together. The odds of 20 cables failing at any given time
was microscopic, but in order for those odds to remain microscopic, the cables
would have to be regularly maintained and examined for corrosion. In addition
to the anti-corrosion coatings applied to each bit of steel wire, cable, and
the tunnel shell itself, American Bridge engineers used a new technology
called Impressed Current Catholic Protection.
Impressed Current Catholic Protection (ICCP for short), involves small amounts
of electric current being passed through the material to be protected. This
electricity will draw any potential corrosion into replaceable anodes of
highly-corrosive material. These anodes absorb the corrosion of the structure
into themselves, and therefore must be replaced as needed. Though this
replacement can be expensive, it is far cheaper than the cost of replacing a
corroded specialty part, or running the risk of a failure in the tunnel. To
protect the whole 90-mile length of the Florida Strait tunnel, one sacrificial
anode has been placed on every other tunnel section. Due to the large area
that must be protected, the anodes corrode on a monthly basis and must be
replaced as part of the regular maintenance schedule.
The steel cable stage of the project was the second most expensive portion of
construction for American Bridge. Of the anticipated $37.4 billion cost, $14
billion was slated for the forging of the steel cables. Construction of the
tunnel sections themselves was only planned to cost $18 billion. During the
1984 American presidential campaign, the enormous size and cost of the steel
cables was seized upon by anti-tunnel politicians as an example of the
impossibility of the project. One fact particularly repeated was the notion
that laid end-to-end, the wire strands of the tunnel's steel cables would
reach over a third of the distance from the Earth to the Sun. Used to justify
the impossibility and waste of the tunnel, President Reagan turned that
argument on its head by using it as an example of human ingenuity and triumph.
American voters evidently agreed with Reagan, who won a large victory in the
November election over Gary Hart.
Five months later and one month following his second inauguration, President
Reagan and Vice-President Gonzales were on hand for a gala ceremony in the
Florida Strait just south of Sand Key as the first tunnel section was lowered
into place. With the Glomar Explorer finally arrived from its West Coast refit
and ready to handle the first of the newly-manufactured tunnel sections, all
was in place for an enormous celebration. On April 17, 1985, that's exactly
what happened. The tunnel's pioneers were all present: Carlito Gonzales,
Andres Aguero, Alan Grant, President Reagan, President Salazar of Cuba, the
members of the JATAC, and most of American Bridge's board of directors. Also
present in force was the media, which covered the event from every conceivable
angle. Speeches by the dignitaries were followed by the breaking of a
ceremonial bottle of champagne on the tunnel section. Difficulties with the
Explorer's equipment meant that the section couldn't actually be lowered into
the water, but that only slightly dampened the holiday mood for those present.
It would be the first and only time that all of the tunnel's organizers were
in one place.
The next day, the ballast tanks of the section were flooded and the section
was lowered into place with the Explorer's enormous grappling claw. The ends
of the steel cables, which had been threaded through grooves on the sides,
top, and bottom of the section, were attached to the concrete weights below
the tunnel by divers wielding enormous bolts. Thanks to the relatively shallow
depth of the first section, the weights were relatively close to the tunnel
shell itself, and could be attached to the cables by divers from the surface,
rather than minisubs, as would have to be the case in deeper water. The entire
process of flooding, lowering, securing the cables, and pumping out the
section's ballast tanks took 35 hours, and it wasn't until the afternoon of
April 19th that the section was completely secure. Aboard the Glomar Explorer
and other ships in the construction flotilla, engineers and tunnel workers
held their breaths. Would the section hold? Would it rip loose from its
moorings?
As the hours passed and divers made repeated inspections of the section, many
of those fears were put to rest. One hundred feet below the surface of the
Florida Strait, the tunnel section rested as solid as a rock. The two-foot
chop on the surface of the Strait had absolutely no effect one hundred feet
down, and it rested solidly for a full week as divers and engineers measured
and re-measured the stresses on the tunnel before the go-ahead was given to
lower the next section and weld it to the first. Of particular concern were
the steel cables that secured the section to the seabed. The four cable
lengths were joined in two A-shaped sections at the forward and rear of the
tunnel section, joining on the top of the tunnel and having a short length of
cable spliced below the tunnel section in order to reduce the tunnel's
potential to roll. Tension measurements taken at different points along the
cables indicated forces similar to those that had been measured in a prototype
section that had been built off the shore of New Jersey and sunk in late 1982,
even before American Tunnel had been awarded the contract for construction.
Though the design had changed greatly in the three years since, the results
were largely the same.
On April 26, the second tunnel section was lowered into position by the
grappler aboard the Glomar Explorer. The process was much the same as what had
happened two weeks prior, but without the fanfare accompanying the first
section. In many ways, the installation of the second and third sections was
far more important than the first. While the first section had been merely a
matter of flooding ballast tanks, securing the section with the anchored steel
cables, and emptying the ballast tanks again, additional sections added
difficulties associated with welding and connecting those sections to those
already laid. These difficulties were partially offset by decisions made in
the design stages of the tunnel plan.
By working southward from the first tunnel section, American Bridge avoided
the problems that would arise from connecting free-floating sections to
sections drilled through the sea floor. The relatively shallow 100-foot depth
of the sections, while deep enough to avoid wave action from even the worst
hurricanes, was still shallow enough for commercial divers to easily access
the sections without the need for long decompression stops. This fact greatly
assisted in the welding of the tunnel sections and the finishing of the tunnel
interiors, which was done almost entirely from divers acting from the surface.
Though most media coverage focused on the minisubs connecting the anchor
cables to the concrete weights a mile below the surface, surface divers did
the vast majority of the work on the tunnel itself. Finally, and perhaps most
importantly to the work being done in the spring and summer of 1985, by
starting work in the relatively shallow water south of Sand Key (itself south
of Key West), workers were able to iron out difficulties in the construction
process without being burdened by the problems associated with deeper water.
The first several miles of construction were all done in water shallow enough
for divers to reach the bottom of the Strait. As time went on, fewer and fewer
needed to descend to any position lower than the tunnel itself, and the
purpose of starting the construction in shallow water was accomplished.
From the time the second tunnel section was secured at the appropriate depth
on April 28, it would take a full week to weld the two sections together.
Balky equipment and inexperienced divers made the work slow, but practice
would eventually speed their efforts. By the end of the year, the welding time
was down to a single day, and by 1987, two sections could be welded together
in just six hours. By mid-May, and with the welding and placement of the fifth
tunnel section, work began on the interior of the tunnel sections. At the
northern end of the tunnel, a temporary end cap was welded into place, a
mirror of the one that provided a water-tight seal on the southern end of the
portions of the tunnel that ran below the reef south of Key West. Between the
fifth and sixth tunnel sections, a steel plate was welded in order to provide
a temporary seal on the end of the tunnel undergoing construction. The plate
was designed to be easily cut away as construction went on, allowing access to
sections to be built in the future. As needed, new plates could be welded in,
providing dry space for laborers to work on the interior of the tunnel.
In many ways, those working on the interior of the unfinished tunnel sections
had the most hazardous jobs of any on the tunnel project. The divers and
minisubs working on the outside might be closer to the ocean, but they had
their own breathing and safety gear. Those inside the tunnel had only a few
emergency breathing packs. At any time, a leak could erupt, filling the dark,
cramped tunnel sections with warm sea water and potential death. The workers
who performed this hazardous work were mostly Cuban and utterly ordinary
except for a strict selection process that weeded out those with
claustrophobia. Light was provided by dozens of electrical lanterns powered by
cables strung by support ships on the surface above. Until the connection of
the submarine sections with those excavated from below the Key West reef in
1988, all the power and air used by the tunnel workers came through a few
small cables and hoses.
With the transportation tubes having been manufactured as part of the tunnel
shell, most of the tunnel workers labored in the cramped confines between the
train tubes and the ballast tanks along the inside of the tunnel shell. The
newly-manufactured shells, kept at a high pressure in order to minimize leaks,
had to be inspected for manufacturing and welding faults and repaired where
necessary. Electrical and telephone cable had to be physically laid in the
tunnel shells, and lighting had to be set up in both the maintenance and
transportation tubes. Finishing the maintenance tube was a priority for the
first builders, as when the tunnel was connected to the Boca Chica end in
1988, it would be used to transport building material.
But before that date, several problems would have to be addressed and solved.
The first, and most pressing of these was the survivability of the tunnel in a
hurricane. The engineers who had designed the tunnel had made their estimates
and designed the tunnel to survive the worst imaginable disaster, but facts
and figures on paper still left many in Washington and Havana unsure about
what the real result would be. In addition, little consideration had been made
as to the tunnel construction itself. When and how would the construction
ships handle evacuation in the path of an approaching storm? Plans were one
thing -- action wholly another. Unfortunately for American Bridge and the
thousands of workers aboard ship in the Florida Strait, there would be plenty
of opportunity to test the effectiveness of those plans.
When the 1985 Atlantic hurricane season opened on June 1, the crew of the
Glomar Explorer was in the process of laying its twelfth tunnel section,
drilling in the seabed below the Sand Key Reef had hit yet another snag,
thanks to seawater seepage through the brittle coral, and the Christopher
Columbus was laying its 5,296th concrete weight in the Florida Strait. But all
eyes were on the weather report, and for what it would bring. For two months,
the fears of those involved in the construction amounted to nothing. The three
storms that formed in July and early August were all too far north to cause
any real concern. On August 12, however, that changed with the formation of
Tropical Storm Danny near the Cayman Islands. As the weathermen watched, Danny
marched northwest, gradually strengthening, and the tunnel workers held their
breaths. But as the track continued, they began to breathe a sigh of relief.
Danny's course took it well to the west of the construction effort, and
although several bands of rain passed over the construction crews, they were
no stronger than any of the thunderstorms that typically hit the area during
the summer rainy season.
The relief that followed the passage of Danny was short-lived. On August 28,
Tropical Depression Elena formed just off the east coast of Cuba. Later that
evening, it was upgraded to a tropical storm. By that time, orders had been
given to the construction fleet to pull up the divers, secure the lines and
cables, and brace for the worst. Aboard the Glomar Explorer, hurried
preparations were made to secure the tunnel shell that the ship had been
placing at the time of the evacuation order. Controversially, the site manager
aboard the Explorer ordered that the shell be secured via its steel cables,
rather than having the shell lifted aboard the ship and transported out of
harm's way. Though the section was in place and secured before Elena's course
brought it across the building site, the Explorer suffered through seas
heavier than anything yet experienced by the ship before reaching a safe
harbor. Portions of the tunnel-gripping crane aboard the Explorer were damaged
during the storm, but only slightly. Far more lasting was the damage to the
site manager's career, as he was immediately released by American Bridge after
word of the incident reached Pittsburgh.
Three days following the incident, the Glomar Explorer was back on station,
laying the next section of tunnel under the command of a new site manager,
promoted from within the tunnel-building operation. Two months of relatively
uneventful tunnel building followed, and work progressed to the satisfaction
of managers at the site and those back at American Bridge headquarters in
Pittsburgh. In early November, however, the tunnel faced the greatest
challenge of its young life with the development of Hurricane Kate, the
latest-developing strong hurricane in recorded history. On November 19, it
lashed the construction sites and the north Cuban coast with winds in excess
of 110 miles an hour (175 km/h). At the land-side tunnel construction sites in
Hershey, construction trailers were overturned and laboring pumps couldn't
keep up with the flood of rainwater that inundated the raw excavations of the
below-ground sections of the Cuban end of the tunnel. By the storm's end, over
$5 million worth of damage had been inflicted on the construction efforts in
Cuba and over a month of work had been lost.
As bad as the situation seemed for those on the ground in Cuba, it could have
been far worse. The experience gained in the evacuation before Hurricane Elena
allowed the ships of the construction fleet to reach safe harbors well in
advance of the storm and for other preparations to be made at sea and ashore.
Though the ships of the fleet were important, they paled in comparison to the
continued survival of the tunnel. If any portion of the tunnel had been
damaged by the comparatively minor Hurricane Elena, there would have had to be
a major re-evaluation of the tunnel plan and potentially a cancellation of the
project altogether. Fortunately, when the ships of the construction fleet
returned to their stations, they found the tunnel, one hundred feet below the
surface, to be completely untouched. In addition, the flooding and winds of
Hurricane Elena allowed for minor modifications to be made in the design of
the tunnel ends and in the clamps connecting the steel cables to the concrete
weights.
The passage of Hurricane Elena, though expensive, provided experience that
would be invaluable in future hurricanes and tropical storms. Perhaps
surprisingly, only six tropical storms or hurricanes hit the construction site
during the time the tunnel was being built. Other storms affected the
construction process (particularly 1992's Hurricane Andrew, which hampered
operations at the Port of Miami), but only six storms brought tropical
storm-force winds or greater to the construction site. Each time, work would
be halted, equipment tied down, and the construction fleet dispersed. Work
might be delayed for up to a one or two days, or even a week, but the
construction process always continued unabated afterward. Often, improvements
were made to correct deficiencies revealed under the extreme conditions of the
storms, leaving the tunnel stronger than before the storm hit.
By Christmas, the damage from Hurricane Elena had been made good in Cuba, and
the Cuban drilling operations were once again on track, moving forward
alongside the American land-side tunnel and the work of the Glomar Explorer,
two portions of the project largely unaffected by the hurricane. With
Christmas also came the end of the hurricane season and the arrival of cooler
weather. Experience earned during the first year of operations, coupled with
pleasant (comparatively) cool and dry weather allowed the crews of the
construction fleet to set records in terms of tunnel constructed and ground
(seabed) covered. It was a pattern that would be repeated for the duration of
the construction project -- work would progress steadily throughout the year,
but greatly increase pace with the arrival of the dry season and cooler
weather in winter. Though the Florida Strait could hardly be called rough
water even at the worst of times (hurricanes excepted), the calmer sea states
that prevailed in winter helped work proceed more quickly. 1986 passed
relatively quietly in terms of construction. The pace of work quickened with
experience, and political arguments over whether the tunnel could be built or
even if it should faded with the public realization that not only could it be
done -- it was being done.
By the summer of 1987 and the return of hurricane season, most people on the
inside of the tunnel project were worrying less about the storm season and
more about the impending political storm surrounding the project. At the time
of the laying of the first tunnel section in the spring of 1985, the political
atmosphere of the tunnel project was a pleasant one, epitomized by the famous
photo of President Reagan and the Cuban president shaking hands on the deck of
the Glomar Explorer with the tunnel section in the background. Later
historians theorized that the calm atmosphere had less to do with a lack of
differences between the Cuban and American positions and more about the need
to address the severe engineering problems that faced the project -- there was
simply no extra effort to spend on ironing out the little political details
that had been missed by the Cuban-American Tunnel Treaty. Discussions were
tabled and decisions pushed back while the Joint American Tunnel
Administration Commission worked on problems associated with the actual
building of the tunnel. With tunnel construction beginning in earnest and most
of the problems ironed out, however, JATAC began to address those political
problems, creating no shortage of friction between the Cubans and Americans
that made up the commission.
One of the key sticking points was the issue of Cuban workers. Due to a clause
in the Tunnel Treaty, 60% of the workers on the tunnel project had to be hired
in Cuba. The problem was that Cuba lacked the numbers of trained workers
needed for the project. Over 60,000 workers would eventually work on the
tunnel and its terminals, meaning that a vast number of workers had to be
hired from Cuban agencies. By 1987, the supply of trained native Cuban workers
was reaching its limits and Cuban agencies began flying in workers from the
United States and Europe to work on the tunnel. When the Chunnel began to
close off the supply of European workers, Asian workers were brought in.
Highly-trained, they had experience that simply couldn't be had in Cuba in the
quantity needed. This "double-dipping," as it became known, was extremely
unpopular among the Cuban members of JATAC and the Tunnel Company who viewed
the construction of the tunnel as a nationalistic enterprise. They viewed the
hiring of outside experts as an insult to Cuba.
Among these was Andres Aguero, who, at age 81, was still the figurehead CEO of
the Florida Strait Tunnel Company, itself a division of American Bridge.
Despite continuing health problems owing to his advanced age that limited his
actual work, Aguero continued to maintain a very visible presence in the
construction process. The informal leader of a coalition that favored closing
the loophole in the Tunnel Treaty that allowed the hiring of foreign and
American workers as part of the 60% mandated in the Treaty. He was opposed by
the board of directors of the Tunnel Company (most of whom were American
Bridge directors as well) and most of the investors behind the project. They
wanted to see the tunnel completed as cheaply and quickly as possible.
Nationalistic concerns, if they had any, came second.
Events came to a head on July 14, when Aguero leaked the minutes of a closed
meeting to the Cuban media in an effort to stir up outside support for his
position. The strategy failed miserably. Though still seen as the Cuban father
of the tunnel, most Cubans (even those of the younger generation) had a desire
to see the tunnel completed, regardless of who actually did the construction.
The prevailing view was that the tunnel itself, rather than the men building
it, would speak to the success of Cuba. To make matters worse, an estimated
20% of the Cuban population owned at least one share in the Tunnel Company.
Most Cubans viewed the purchase as a point of pride, something they could
point to and say they were help building the tunnel in their own small way.
Few viewed the shares as any sort of real investment on which they would
receive a financial return. This view was also present in the United States,
but on a much, much smaller scale. Those Americans who did invest in the
tunnel in that manner were far more fanatical about it, but they were also
fewer on the ground.
For Aguero, the end result of all this was a speedy and ungraceful ouster from
his position at the head of the Tunnel Company. The firing was couched in
terms of a "retirement for health reasons" to avoid irritating investors who
supported Aguero, but it was clear to most outside observers that Aguero had
worn out his welcome. The man who, for 15 years, had campaigned for the
construction of a tunnel between Florida and Cuba now was on the outside
looking in. Replacing him as head of the Tunnel Company was one of the three
engineers who had worked with him on the project from the beginning. Manuel
Cereijo, born in 1943, had been assigned by the Cuban government to Aguero's
little committee in 1972 as part of their plan to keep Aguero out of the way.
But Cereijo had been taken with Aguero's plans and had stuck with the former
president through thick and thin, and now he had been hand-picked to succeed
the man. A non-political figure, Cereijo had been chosen for his engineering
acumen, not any particular managerial skill. It was fully expected by members
of the company's directors that a new CEO would have to be chosen when the
tunnel was completed, preferably someone with the public relations skills and
economic expertise to turn a profit. Things wouldn't quite turn out that way.
Andres Aguero, meanwhile, quietly entered a private hospital two weeks after
his July 17 dismissal for complications related to a case of the flu he had
caught during his final days in office. He was released two months later, but
suffered a minor stroke in Spring 1988. Confined to bed, he demanded a hospice
with a view of Havana harbor, where he watched boats arriving from and
departing for the construction site. Weekly reports from Cereijo kept him
informed about the progress of construction.
For the most part, the men (and a few women) working on the tunnel project
took little notice of the changes at the top of the Tunnel Company, which had
little direct effect on day-to-day progress. The most immediate change for the
construction crews was an influx of trained Europeans who replaced
site-trained Cubans over the summer of 1987. Ironically, these replacements
actually tended to slow progress when compared with the pace of the Cubans who
had previously filled positions on the project. Though less experienced at
ocean construction projects in general, they had been trained on-site in every
particular of the world's largest and most difficult construction project.
Many of the men who were replaced had skills learned on the job that couldn't
be found in any new hire. After this fact was realized, the replacement of
Cuban workers with foreigners was scaled back, and many of the men who had
lost their jobs to Europeans found themselves re-hired a few months later.
Eventually, a capable mix of Cuban, American, and foreign workers resulted.
Ironically, it was a mix closer to the system envisioned by Aguero than the
one put forward by his opponents at American Bridge and on the Tunnel
Company's board of directors.
Manuel Cereijo, meanwhile, was busily settling into his new position as Chief
Executive of the Tunnel Company, where he soon found that his duties largely
entailed staying out of the way while the board of directors made their
decisions. They had chosen him as an amiable non-entity who could be counted
on to say all the right things on television and who had worked on the tunnel
long enough to be taken seriously. For his first three months in the position,
he did exactly that. On October 19, 1987, that all changed. On that date,
known as "Black Monday" in the United States, stock markets worldwide suffered
their largest single-day drops ever. In the United States, the Dow Jones lost
23% of its value. The Cuban stock market in Havana dropped by 18%. Suddenly,
Tunnel Company shares, considered as close to a sure bet as anything in the
stock market, became a risky investment along with everything else traded on
the public markets.
Many investors panicked, fearing the recurrence of another Great Depression,
which had been triggered by a similar selloff way back in 1929. Many Tunnel
Company investors unloaded their shares in haste, hoping to minimize their
losses. These sales triggered others, which in turn triggered others, and the
ripple effect threatened to spread, following the same pattern in companies
from Hong Kong to London to New York to Havana. In an emergency meeting of the
Tunnel Company board of directors, debate raged as to what, if anything,
should be done. While serious, the selloff was not fatal, and in the long run
might even be a good thing as vacillating investors sold their shares to more
stable individuals. But that was a long-term outlook and wouldn't matter if
the bleeding couldn't be stopped in the short term. Possibilities and
suggestions flew back and forth across the boardroom table of the Tunnel
Company's headquarters in Miami. Manuel Cereijo remained silent through most
of the meeting, his head swiveling back and forth as if following a tennis
match. Shortly after midnight, he spoke for only the second time during the
meeting.
His suggestion, thrown into the mix of possible corporate bandaids, was to
begin selling tickets for tunnel trips as soon as possible. The idea didn't
come completely out of left field -- the marketing department of the Tunnel
Company had been debating the subject for several weeks, with many different
options flying around. But Cereijo's suggestion was to start the sales far
sooner than even the earliest marketing plan. The suggestion had several
positives: it would generate revenue for the company, cause an uptick in
publicity, but most importantly, it would engender confidence in the project.
Cereijo argued that with tickets in hand, potential investors would feel far
more confident that the tunnel would ultimately be completed. The biggest
argument against the plan (and it was a big one) was that with less than
one-fifth of the tunnel sections laid, let alone completed, the beginning of
ticket sales could be seen a desperation move, potentially causing even bigger
drops in Tunnel Company share prices. Other arguments against offering tickets
for sale at such an early date dealt with the logistics of the sale -- who
would sell the tickets, how the ticketing system would work, and how much the
tickets would cost.
The debate lasted several days, but in the end it was the continued
instability in share prices that decided matters for the board. By a 5-3 vote,
Cereijo's suggestion became company policy. On Wednesday, October 21, the
Company issued a press release stating that on November 1, 1987, the first
tickets for the Florida Strait Tunnel would go on sale as part of a
limited-time advance offering. Individual tickets would be priced at $35 USD,
and would include passage for one automobile and one passenger. Additional
passenger spaces could be purchased for $7 atop the initial $35 cost. Tickets
would be offered for sale through various travel agents and ticket brokers.
The announcement proved to be successful in stabilizing the Company's stock
price, and when November 1 rolled around, over 5,000 tickets were sold on the
first day alone. 20,000 were sold in the first week, and by the time the
two-week offering ended, nearly 50,000 tickets had been sold. Cereijo's
suggestion had worked to perfection, and the new CEO of the tunnel company was
suddenly seen as a bit more than just a placeholder. Meanwhile, construction
continued unabated by any financial fluctuations.
It was, however, affected by other events outside the normal course of
construction. The first of these events came courtesy of the state of Florida,
which was naturally eager to capitalize on the tunnel's construction and
(eventual) completion. To service the immense number of cars and trucks that
were predicted to travel to Cuba via the tunnel, the Florida Department of
Transportation (FDOT) in 1983 unveiled an immense plan to expand and extend
Interstate 95 from its southern terminus in Miami an additional 150 miles
southward to Boca Chica. In Miami, the Interstate would be expanded from four
lanes to eight, and four elevated, non-stop lanes of brand new interstate
would be constructed from Homestead southward. While the Boca Chica extension
was a relatively new addition to the plan, the issue of expanding I-95 in
Miami had been hotly-debated since the mid-1970s.
By 1983, however the original four lanes of I-95 were proving catastrophically
inadequate to service Miami's exploding population. Thanks to Miami's
reputation as an easy-going, tropical, relaxed city, millions of retirees and
Americans seeking a change in scenery had flocked to the burgeoning
metropolis. The city's road infrastructure, designed in the early-to-mid
1960s, failed to keep up thanks to protests from local businesses who were
afraid that the construction of new elevated highways would mean potential
customers could bypass their small stores. Eventually the need for expansion
became dire enough to drown out their cries, and in 1983, the state of Florida
began a road-building spree that continued right up to this day. Between
Orlando and Boca Chica, a driver will today face over a dozen construction
sites, with the orange-and-yellow barrels defining construction zones becoming
a constant companion.
By 1987, FDOT's plan had finally broken ground after four years of legal and
political wrangling. The mayor of Miami, in a televised ceremony, pressed a
button that demolished 11 buildings that would be the site of I-95's first
steps south to Boca Chica. Despite the opening of construction, opposition
still continued, both in Miami and in Key West. In the Southernmost city,
like-minded environmentalists and locals who feared the environmental damage
that the highway expansion and tunnel construction would cause, formed the
group Last Stand. The members of the appropriately-named group viewed
themselves as the last barrier to the destruction of the fragile environment
of the Florida Keys, which had originally been protected by national parks and
refuges designated during the Brown presidency. Now, dispensations granted by
the Reagan administration to the highway and tunnel builders threatened to
destroy everything they thought saved.
Last Stand's anti-outsider and pro-environment message found fertile ground
among the people of the Florida Keys, who had always been insular, separated
by distance and accessibility from the growing population of mainland Florida.
Now, they found themselves seemingly threatened by a flood of newcomers and
building projects that threatened to destroy the environmental beauty that
made the Keys a popular tourist destination, even with the attractions of
Havana just a few hours away. Beginning in 1984, Last Stand-supported
candidates began to win local elections. First by small margins, but as the
movement gained steam, greater and greater margins and landslides became the
rule. In 1987, virtually every major candidate in Monroe County and Key West
was in some way affiliated with Last Stand. This association manifested itself
in all sorts of minor annoyances for companies seeking to build in the Florida
Keys. Taxes, duties, fees, and other costs suddenly manifested themselves for
new construction, ushered in by new county ordinances. The affected companies
simply bit the bullet and paid the higher costs, and also redoubled their
efforts to portray themselves as doing something positive for the Florida
Keys.
These efforts were less than successful, but so were Last Stand's supporters'
efforts at slowing or stopping the construction springing up across the Keys.
The two biggest construction projects -- the I-95 expansion and the tunnel
project were federally-funded and therefore untouchable by local government.
The taxes and fees instituted by the county began to backfire -- hampering
businesses from opening new locations and expanding to take advantage of the
new growth. Instead of opening offices in the Keys, construction firms and
other commercial interests instead expanded operations in Collier and
Miami-Dade Counties, which were only a few hours by water from Key West and
the tunnel, anyway. Even with the added transportation needed, the cost was
still less than scaling the financial walls erected by the county commission.
Stymied by their own moves, and pressured by Monroe County voters, the county
commission took a radical new tack in an effort to stir outside public opinion
and seceded from the United States. In a one-minute ceremony in Key West, the
commissioners voted themselves out of the Union, proclaimed the creation of
the "Conch Republic," and promptly surrendered to a representative of the U.S.
Navy. Ceremonial "battles" of water hoses and thrown stale bread were held
between civilian vessels and the Coast Guard, and protesters demonstrated on
the bridge connecting Boca Chica Key to the northbound lanes of U.S. 1,
blocking them to construction traffic. The "secession" was covered widely in
the national media, including on television by CNN.
Unfortunately for the county commissioners and supporters of Last Stand, most
of the United States and Cuba reacted with surprising hostility to the
"secession," which was seen largely as a publicity stunt outside of south
Florida. Outside observers simply saw the protesters and county commissioners
as a few closed-minded southerners holding up progress for the rest of the
country. In the United States, where an estimated 73% of the population
supported the tunnel's construction, the protest went over like a lead
balloon. In television coverage of the event, the clean-cut spokespeople made
an impression where the crude-but-straightforward spokespeople for Last Stand
did not. In Cuba, there was even less support for Last Stand's position.
Thanks to the widespread purchase of Tunnel Company shares and the widespread
perception that the tunnel was the next step in Cuba becoming a global leader,
none of Last Stand's arguments resonated with Cubans. Perhaps if the Florida
Keys had been a depressed area with an ailing economy and pleading for federal
government aid, the protest would have been a successful one.
Though their gambit had failed, Last Stand's position didn't become completely
hopeless until 1988, when a public meeting between Tunnel Company
representatives and the county government devolved into violent shouts and
arguments, including one death threat on a Tunnel Company officer by a Vice
President of Last Stand. Charges were eventually brought against the
individual, and he was sentenced to five years in state prison for the threat.
After that point, Last Stand began to lose its influence in local politics,
and never really recovered the momentum of the mid-1980s. Though unsuccessful
in stopping or even slowing the construction spreading across the Keys, Last
Stand eventually managed to extract tens of millions of dollars from the
Tunnel Company for environmental restoration, mitigation, and research. Today,
Last Stand continues in a far more stable legacy as a watchdog group for the
Florida Keys and has recovered from its disastrous 1987 gambit.
Of course, work on the tunnel itself never stopped through all of these
background arguments. Even with the beginning of construction on the I-95
extension, the vast majority of construction material continued to arrive by
sea. The two narrow lanes of U.S. 1 were simply inadequate to provide the
constant flow of men and equipment that were needed. Not until 1995, eight
years after the beginning of the extension project, did large amounts of
equipment begin to arrive via the long land route from Miami. At sea was where
the work took place, and at sea was where the tunnel's supply lines rested.
1988 was a milestone year in the construction of the Florida Strait Tunnel. In
March, Andres Aguero, Cuba's "Father of the Tunnel," suffered a minor stroke
that left him in a coma for several months. He would never regain the physical
or mental acuity he had prior to the stroke, but would survive for nine more
years. Though sad, the event didn't affect the continuing construction of the
tunnel, which was now crossing some of the deepest portions of the Florida
Strait. In June, drilling on the Boca Chica end of the tunnel was pronounced
complete and the floating portions of the tunnel were attached to land for the
first time. In July, Last Stand faced an epic public relations disaster with
the imprisonment of one of their vice presidents, lifting a public relations
roadblock for the Tunnel Company. And in November, the Christopher Columbus
finally completed its four-year mission of laying the concrete counterweights
that would restrain the tunnel, preventing its buoyant structure from rising
the hundred feet to the surface of the Strait.
Both the completion of the weight-laying project and the connection of the
tunnel to its northern landward end were critically important to the long-term
completion of the project, but the connection to Boca Chica was perhaps more
important in the immediate term. With the completion of the land connection,
supplies and workers could now be brought down without the aid of divers and
real work on finishing the interior of the tunnel shell could begin. Of
course, connecting the suspended sections of the tunnel to the portions
excavated from the coral of Boca Chica wasn't a simple matter of just dropping
in another tunnel section, welding it into place, and pumping out the
seawater. The tunnel sections connecting the northern and southern ends of the
suspended tunnel to the portions of the tunnel dug belowground were different
from the rest of the tunnel in several ways.
Shortly after American Bridge acquired the Tunnel Company and won the bidding
for the tunnel contract, the engineers working on the final design for the
tunnel ran into a problem. The trains running through any planned tunnel would
be traveling at an enormous rate of speed -- potentially several hundred miles
an hour. These trains would naturally impart some of their enormous momentum
on the tracks below. On a normal railroad, this momentum doesn't matter
because the rails are securely fastened to the roadbed and the ground, and
cannot move. In the tunnel, the rails would be attached to the tunnel shell,
floating free in the waters of the Florida Strait, held in place only by its
buoyancy and the cables restraining it. These would prevent side-to-side and
up-and-down movement for the tunnel, but nothing would prevent the tunnel from
moving forward or backward along its 90-mile length. As a train travels from
the portion of the tunnel dug through the coral below Sand Key to the portion
of the tunnel floating free, it "pushes" against the floor of the tunnel and
creates a pressure wave that travels forward and backward along the tunnel.
The faster a train goes when crossing from one portion of the tunnel to the
other, the worse the pressure wave.
As the engineers determined, a solid steel tunnel might be able to withstand
the force of that momentum for a few dozen times, but eventually the
northernmost and southernmost tunnel sections would shatter under the strain
of the pressure waves created by the passage of the trains, flooding the
tunnel. Several options were discussed, including scheduling simultaneous
north- and southbound trains so that their pressure waves would cancel each
other out. This was deemed impractical due to the restraints it would place on
scheduling trains, limiting the tunnel's flexibility to handle large numbers
of travelers. Due to this fact, the designers incorporated two enormous shock
absorbers into the final tunnel design. One would be located at the northern
Boca Chica end of the suspended sections of the tunnel, while the other would
be located at the Hershey, Cuba end of the tunnel. In understanding these
shock absorbers, it's important to note that the actual movement of the tunnel
was minor (during the worst simulated pressure waves, the tunnel moved at a
rate of less than one inch/sec) -- it was the enormous mass of the tunnel,
coupled with the repeated shocks caused by passing trains, that caused
problems.
Construction of the shock absorbers began in 1984, shortly after the freezing
of the tunnel design. Almost immediately, problems began to develop. The
amount of force needed to restrain the advance of the multi-million-ton mass
of the tunnel burst hydraulic cylinders in testing. Friction-based shock
absorbers proved inadequate, and other solutions proved either too expensive
or simply impractical. In the end, the designers compromised. The final design
for the "portal" sections of the tunnel (the sections joining the excavated
tunnel to the floating tunnel) incorporated the largest practical system of
shock absorbers and stabilizers. To prevent them from bursting under the
strain of the pressure waves, the tunnel engineers mandated a 75 mph speed
limit for trains passing through the portal sections. While in the floating
sections of tunnel or in the short stretches of excavated tunnel at the
beginning and end of the trip, the trains would be free to accelerate to their
top speed of 170 mph. But while passing through the portals, they had to be
limited to a fraction of that speed in order to avoid damaging the tunnel. The
managers of the Tunnel Company were understandably upset, but the cost of
engineering a better solution would have far exceeded the gains to be made.
In recent years, the Tunnel Company has announced plans to upgrade the
tunnel's shock absorbers to incorporate state-of-the-art magneto rheological
dampers into the tunnel in an effort to eliminate the 75 mph speed
restriction. However, this upgrade is not scheduled to take place until the
2030 remodeling, by which time the tunnel will have recouped its initial
construction costs.
The emplacement of the northern portal section took place on June 27, 1988. By
this time, the crew of the Glomar Explorer had three full years of
tunnel-building experience and even the ungainly structure of the specialized
tunnel section couldn't prevent the Explorer from emplacing, welding, and
pumping out the section in less than two days. On June 30, Manuel Cereijo
became the first person to walk from the excavated portions of the tunnel and
into a floating section. He was met in a short ceremony by the combined diving
crews who had been working on the interiors of the tunnel shell even before
the connection to land was established. Cereijo was a popular man with the
everyday workers, and the applause he received during the ceremony was mostly
genuine. His engineering background, coupled with his continued support for
higher pay and good working conditions made him popular among the workers, if
not with the Tunnel Company's shareholders and parent company, American
Bridge. Though that support would cause his "reassignment" to the position of
chief engineer in 1989 (a de-facto demotion) at the time Cereijo was still
riding high off the successful initial ticket offering and the support that
followed.
The men he met were the hardiest, most elite of the divers, welders, and
builders that worked on the entire project. 45,000 people could make the claim
of having worked on the project directly -- with another 10,000 working in
offices ashore. Just over 1,000 of those made the hundred-foot dive down
through an airlock to the dark, pressurized tube that was the tunnel before
the connection to land. Tenuously supplied with light and air via cables from
the surface, any accident was inevitably serious and potentially fatal. Even a
minor injury meant a long ascent to the surface and a probable stay in a
decompression chamber before any treatment. Three of the 14 fatalities that
took place during tunnel construction happened among those thousand workers
during the three years they went to work in isolation, a higher percentage
than for any other segment of construction.
The photo taken of the meeting between Cereijo and the "grunts," as they were
known, is perhaps the most iconic image of the entire tunnel construction
project. The meeting ceremony took place with none of the ceremony that
surrounded the laying of the first tunnel section. Instead of pomp and
circumstance, there was simply one group of grim-faced men meeting another
group of men. On the left side of the photograph are the grunts, almost
shadowed into obscurity by the lack of light in the floating sections of the
tunnel -- after all, when all your electricity came through a thin set of
cables from the surface, you had to be economical. On the right side of the
photograph are the illuminated workers of a new shift, clean-faced and
illuminated by the lights attached to the portal section, but wearing
expressions no less determined than those of the grunts. In the center is
Cereijo, hand extended toward that of a grunt, looking not at the camera, but
toward the worker walking toward him. It wasn't a picture that was circulated
widely -- indeed at all -- by the Tunnel Company's PR department, but by the
time the last section of tunnel was laid, it became the picture that
symbolized the effort, the men, and everything else about the construction
project.
Workers and equipment could now travel nearly ten miles south of Sand Key
without the use of a boat. Priority was placed on improving the maintenance
tunnel sections of the tunnel shell, which would be the primary route for
workers to travel before and after completion. The maintenance tunnel was also
sealed and pressurized in the completed sections, creating a safe haven in the
event of catastrophic flooding. Until the completion of the rails in the two
train tubes, heavy equipment could also be driven down those sections of the
tunnel shell, speeding progress. The work, however, was still limited by the
number of tunnel sections welded into place, and that project continued to
move slowly.
In November, the Christopher Columbus completed its three-year task of laying
the concrete foundation weights for the tunnel. Stretching the 90 miles from
Sand Key to just north of the coast of Cuba, the weights were the first
portion of the tunnel project to stretch the entire route from the Florida
Keys to Cuba. In the three months that followed the completion of the
Columbus's mission, the ship was docked in Havana Harbor, where it underwent
refits and repairs in order to take its place as the flagship of the
tunnel-laying fleet working from the Cuban coast northward. Just as the Glomar
Explorer worked to grip the enormous tunnel sections with its crane, so too
would the Columbus. Owing to the Columbus's smaller size, it was somewhat less
capable and worked slightly slower, but it was still remarkably effective and
almost doubled the pace at which tunnel sections were welded into place. By
March 1989, the Columbus was on-site north of Cuba, working towards the center
of the Strait. Owing to the later start, the first section laid by the
Columbus was the portal section, which allowed for easy access to the interior
of the tunnel shells on the Cuban leg of the project.
As the Columbus tied up to its Havana dock, the United States was electing a
new president. Owing to term limits, President Reagan couldn't run for a third
term. Vice President Gonzales, surprisingly, decided not to put his name
forward as a candidate. In a public statement, he declared that he had "become
tired of politics as usual," and announced that he would not seek his party's
nomination. At the time, pundits speculated that the announcement stemmed from
a series of difficult political defeats, including the defeat of the Equal
Rights Amendment, which Gonzales had supported. They also pointed to the
continuing illness of Gonzales's son, who was stricken with leukemia.
Regardless of his reasoning, Gonzales's refusal to seek the nomination left
the door open for Democrats Jesse Jackson and Albert Gore, whose balanced
ticket saw both ushered into office by a large margin. As both men supported
the tunnel project and had vowed to continue Reagan's campaign of "Rebuilding
America," work on the tunnel continued unabated.
As 1988 turned into 1989, the smooth sailing of the tunnel construction crews
was not echoed in the ranks of the Tunnel Company managers and board of
directors. Manuel Cereijo, who had been appointed CEO in late 1987, came under
increasing fire from the board of directors and much of the company's
stockholders. His pro-worker policies, though making him popular among the
rank-and-file, contributed to rising construction costs and erased the good
will he had generated during the company's initial advance ticket sales. That
idea, though successful, couldn't completely counter the continued missteps
that he, as an engineer with limited hands-on experience, kept blundering
into. By April 1989, events surrounding Cereijo climaxed when the Tunnel
Company's annual fiscal report revealed that expenditures were running five
percent above expectations thanks to Cereijo's unwillingness to compromise on
employee raises and benefits. Five percent may not sound like much, but when
the total amount is upwards of $5 billion, five percent amounts to tens of
millions of dollars. In May, Cereijo was voted out and a search for a new CEO
began.
The board of directors didn't have far to look -- former Vice President
Carlito Gonzales, whose son had finally lost his battle with leukemia, came to
the company looking to fill the position. Privately, he hoped that by throwing
himself into his work, he could avoid thinking about the death of his son.
Voted in as CEO just a few months later, Gonzales found that work and the
board of directors seemingly found the savior it was looking for.
Gonzales immediately faced several problems that had arisen as a result of
Cereijo's firing. Anxious workers who feared pay cuts, layoffs, or a loss in
benefits as a result of Cereijo's departure were threatening a strike, and
that was a problem that had to be fixed as soon as possible. With the skill of
a trained politico, Gonzales negotiated a new contract with the workers that
promised not to cut benefits but also stated that they would not be increased
for several years in order to balance the company's books. Cereijo was
"reassigned" to a position as chief engineer of the project, a position for
which he was far better suited, anyway. Cuban stockholders, angered at the
loss of a high-profile Cuban representative in the project had to have their
fears allayed, and Gonzales embarked on a goodwill tour to do just that. In
speeches across Cuba, he played up his Cuban ancestry and tried to make it
clear that his hiring was not the sign of an American takeover, and that the
tunnel was a Cuban project just as much as it was an American one. Though a
small protest sell-off still took place, the Cubans who owned one or two
shares each (and collectively owned upwards of a third of the entire Tunnel
Company stock), by and large held on to their stock. Deftly and with no small
amount of political skill, Gonzales defused each of the problems that had been
caused by Cereijo's "reassignment." Work on the tunnel progressed unabated.
The first few weeks of Gonzales's tenure saw the lowering and welding of the
first switchover section of the tunnel. The switchover sections are 400-foot
long tunnel sections designed to allow trains to switch from one train tube to
the other so that if a section of track needs to be taken off line for
maintenance, the entire 98-mile length of the tunnel does not need to be shut
down. Six of these double-size tunnel sections are built into the 80 miles of
floating tunnel -- one every 13.3 miles. The enormous size of the switchover
sections caused problems aboard the Glomar Explorer when it was time for the
first one to be emplaced. Several motors on the Explorer's crane burnt out
under the enormous weight of the section, and it took three times the normal
length of time for the section to be fully welded into place. With practice
comes skill, however, and the five remaining switchover sections were emplaced
more quickly each time. The switchover sections are unique in that in the
event of an emergency, they can be completely sealed and effectively serve as
a lifeboat in the event of a catastrophic disaster. The end result is an
up-scaled version of the maintenance tube, which itself is pressurized and can
serve as a rescue area. The switchover sections are, unlike the maintenance
tube, over-engineered to the point that they can survive the pressures at the
bottom of the Florida Strait, so that in the worst possible disaster --
several tunnel sections ruptured, the ballast tanks of the switchover section
destroyed -- a rescue may become possible using the minisubs of the Tunnel
Authority. Detractors are quick to point out, however, that a disaster of the
magnitude needed to destroy the ballast tanks in the switchover section would
also damage the structural integrity of the section enough that it would be
unlikely to survive a trip to the bottom of the Strait.
Throughout 1989, construction continued at a steady pace both in the Florida
Straits and ashore. While the Christopher Columbus, Glomar Explorer, and
thousands of hired divers continued to lay and weld tunnel sections in the
warm waters of the Strait, thousands of other workers labored on the
infrastructure leading to the tunnel terminals and on the terminals
themselves. In New York, Havana, and London, other men worked -- the bankers
and financial officers that kept the money coming. And around the world, men
and women just like those employed by the Tunnel Company worked on dozens of
other tunnel projects. In Japan, the Seikan tunnel enjoyed its first year of
operation. Beneath the English Channel, British and French engineers labored
behind their enormous Tunnel Boring Machines. And in the Soviet Union, Soviet
engineers labored in vain on a grand tunnel project to match that of the
United States and Cuba. While the world watched the fall of the Berlin Wall,
those same men received the news that the Wall was not the only thing falling
that night – the Soviet tunnel, located beneath the Urals, and which had been
planned as part of a grand plan for the Trans-Soviet Highway – was cancelled
on the same night.
In the United States and Cuba, work continued.
Ashore, both in Cuba and on Boca Chica Key, work began on the permanent
terminal and administrative buildings for the Tunnel Company. In Hershey,
construction continued on an enormous complex of buildings. Everything from
ordinary offices to train yards to the southern terminal of the Florida Strait
Tunnel were needed, and although some temporary buildings had previously been
erected to fill the needs of the construction process, few permanent buildings
had been built by the time construction began in earnest in the middle of
1989.
The first priority for the builders was securing an adequate supply of
electricity for the tunnel complex and for the tunnel itself. 98 miles of
electrified track use a great deal of electricity, and initial plans for the
tunnel involved the construction of a dedicated power plant in Hershey to meet
the demand. As costs rose, however, those plans were shelved in favor of
dedicated lines connecting the tunnel to the Cuban and American power grids.
The Hershey terminal, which is the most visible portion of the tunnel complex
to visitors, borrows heavily from the beaux arts-style architecture still
present on many older Havana buildings, and which was seeing a resurgence in
the late 1980s. The heavy gilding and ornate decorations sprayed across the
exterior of these buildings had gone out of style in the 1960s, but the
architect of the Hershey terminal chose to take advantage of that history,
rather than using a brutalist or futurist approach in the style of the LAX
airport terminal in Los Angeles or the Boca Chica terminal, which was being
built less than a hundred miles to the north.
Beneath the surface of its beaux-arts exterior, which resembles a color- and
fresco-splattered version of New York City’s Grand Central Terminal, is a
rather ordinary platform and underground tunnel that slowly rises from the
portal tunnel section at the coast to Hershey, one mile inland. Again, the
greater amount of space available allows for a more conventional approach than
the one needed in the confined space of Boca Chica Key.
Initially, plans called for the high-speed tunnel railway to connect directly
to a series of high-speed railway tracks connecting Hershey to Havana,
Camaguey, and the rest of Cuba’s large cities. Again, rising costs stopped
this from taking place. With billions of dollars diverted to tunnel
construction and investment, it became politically impossible for even more
money to be spent on high-speed railways. Conventional trains and roads would
have to do, at least to start. (Next year, an extension of the high-speed
railway is scheduled to reach Havana, 15 miles to the west.)
The terminals and roadways are arranged around the tunnel terminal like spokes
radiating from a central point, and a visitor today will find virtually every
space filled with automobiles of all kinds. That fact stems from a decision
made during the construction process, one made in ignorance and no small bit
of racism. The American designers of the tunnel complex anticipated a flood of
automobile traffic from the north – American tourists heading south to the
casinos and beaches of Cuba – and made plans to meet that flood. Space was
designated and machinery designed to allow the quick unloading of automobiles
recently arrived from Boca Chica. Much less thought was given to traffic
heading north. After all, vacationers (according to computer simulations)
tended to arrive en masse and depart separately, depending on the length of
the vacation, so much less time was devoted to designing an optimum loading
setup for vehicles heading north.
Almost immediately after the opening of the tunnel and the Hershey tunnel, the
designers’ mistake was realized. Not only were large numbers of Americans
heading south, large numbers of Cubans were heading north. The signing of the
North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) in 1992, coupled with the
free-trade clauses of the Tunnel Treaty made the United States as attractive a
destination for Cubans as Cuba was for Americans. The number of Cubans heading
north vastly exceeded the expectations of the systems designers that had
designed the loading and unloading techniques perfected on computers and put
into place in the design of the Hershey terminal.
To be fair, NAFTA was a development that took place three years after
construction began on the terminal itself, and several years after the design
simulations had been conducted. Despite that fact, the long lines heading
north engendered no shortage of short tempers and angry accusations that the
American engineers had deliberately overlooked the needs of ordinary Cubans in
favor of American tourists. A hasty redesign of the loading and unloading
system followed, and three years after the initial opening of the tunnel, the
new system was put into place. Though it did relieve the worst of the crowding
and traffic jams, congestion near the Hershey terminal is still enormous
today. The opening of the direct Havana-Boca Chica high-speed rail route next
year is expected to help the situation, but extensive delays are likely to
continue well into the future.
Ironically, the Boca Chica Terminal, which required enormous effort and
planning in order to avoid congestion on the cramped confines of Boca Chica
Key has been less affected by congestion than Hershey. Though traffic is still
heavy on a daily basis both in the terminal and on I-95 to and from Miami, it
moves steadily in a way that drivers waiting in Hershey can only dream of.
Construction on the Boca Chica Terminal began in 1988, one year earlier than
in Hershey. Unlike in Cuba, where massive amounts of space were available for
an enormous terminal complex, the limited space available on Boca Chica means
that the northern terminus of the tunnel consists solely of the terminal
building and the parking and transportation infrastructure needed to keep the
automobiles and passengers moving south. Because of that limited space, the
designers of the northern terminal faced a unique challenge. Though the
northern portal section of the tunnel (the switchover between floating and
excavated tunnel) was below Sand Key three miles south, there simply wasn’t
room to create a gradually sloping tunnel to the surface as in Cuba. The
northern end of the tunnel had to be driven deep, below the coral reef that
provides so much of the tourism for the Florida Keys.
This fact meant that if the tunnel was to reach the surface of Boca Chica Key,
it would have needed to travel an angle steeper than 45 degrees in order to
climb the hundred feet separating the normal depth of the tunnel with the
surface. This angle proved to be far too steep for the high-speed trains to
travel, and so the terminal designers had to come up with a solution. As they
dithered and debated, drawing up dozens of outlandish – and expensive –
solutions, work on the tunnel continued. By 1987, the floating portions of the
tunnel were nearly ready to be connected to the tunnel excavated below the
reef. A decision had to be made quickly. Facing a rapidly-approaching
deadline, they did what politicians and architects alike have done throughout
history – they compromised.
During the construction process for the portions of the tunnel excavated from
below Boca Chica, the reef, and Sand Key, a vertical shaft had been sunk one
hundred feet down on Boca Chica in order to provide access for the
construction workers. Though never designed for anything more than temporary
construction access, the architects of the Boca Chica terminal seized on the
hundred-foot shaft as a solution to their problems. If they couldn’t bring the
train to the terminal, why couldn’t they bring the terminal to the train?
And so, in 1988, construction began on the Boca Chica terminal – one hundred
feet below the surface of Boca Chica Key. The decision to place the terminal a
hundred feet below ground created many problems and several opportunities for
the terminal builders. First and foremost was the problem of expanding the
cavern and building the terminal while construction traffic bound for portions
of the tunnel further south continued to flow. The congestion created by all
the construction vehicles needed for both terminal and tunnel construction
created what one pundit called “the worst underground traffic jam in history.”
Expanding the cavern below Boca Chica caused problems of its own, beyond
creating congestion. The method used to create the cavern in the first place –
the New Austrian Tunneling method – involved digging the shaft, spraying the
walls with adhesive in order to prevent cave-ins from the porous coral rock,
then putting up a concrete liner to prevent water leakage. This method didn’t
lend itself to easy expansion of the cavern, which had been constructed
initially to serve as a marshaling area for equipment destined for the tunnel
further south. Breaking the concrete liners caused flooding, and work on the
tunnel itself was delayed multiple times as work on the terminal caused
seawater flooding that threatened to inundate the cavern below Boca Chica.
After one incident where the flooding was severe enough to overwhelm the
pumps, forcing divers to be brought in to stop the flooding, engineers began
deepening the cavern by twenty feet. This digging created a “bilge space” for
the cavern, creating a holding area for even the worst flood. Just as a bilge
operates on a naval vessel, holding any water that leaks through the hull,
this twenty-foot-deep space prevented sea water from overwhelming the
construction site again. Following the completion of the cavern, the bilge
space served good use as equipment space for the ventilators, generators, and
electrical transformers used in the terminal.
As work on the cavern continued through 1989 and 1990, engineers and
architects debated the solution to the biggest problem created by placing the
terminal underground – how to get the thousands of automobiles and passengers
that would travel to Cuba – one hundred feet down to the trains. As before,
they looked to the way the tunnel construction crew had solved the same
problem.
After the drilling of the vertical construction shaft, tunnel workers had
installed a series of enormous elevators in order to transport equipment and
supplies one hundred feet down. Though slow and ungainly, the hydraulic
elevators were strong enough to lift and lower the bulky drills, miners, and
other equipment needed for the excavation and construction of the tunnel.
Spiral ramps, such as used in parking garages, were an option, but the size of
the equipment that needed to be lowered ruled out their use. The same
circumstances precluded the use of spiral ramps for the loading of the
automobile trains – there simply wouldn’t be enough room for the
eighteen-wheelers that were projected to use the tunnel.
And so the architects and engineers of the terminal were forced to use the
same method of transportation that construction vehicles used – an elevator.
Four of them, to be exact – two for loading vehicles and two for unloading
vehicles. The elevators, as designed, were some of the largest moving
structures in the world and presented no shortage of problems. In order to
load and unload the automobile cars in the tunnel trains rapidly enough, each
elevator needed to transport fifty midsize automobiles in a single trip.
Because of this fact, each of the elevator platforms measured over 10,000
square feet in size. This necessitated the drilling of four new shafts through
the porous coral rock of Boca Chica Key and the whole process took almost as
long as the construction of the terminal itself.
The unique loading and unloading system required skilled and experienced
operators to work efficiently, and even before the system’s completion,
operators and guidelines had to be worked out. With trains potentially coming
in and departing on an hourly basis, loading schedules and techniques needed
to be figured out in order to avoid accidents and ensure the greatest possible
efficiency. Computerized efficiency programs, a novelty in the late 1980s and
early 1990s, were used extensively in the planning and development process.
Space for approximately two hundred vehicles (semi-trailers would take up more
space) was anticipated in the planned tunnel trains. Loading the train to its
maximum capacity would require two full elevator-loads of vehicles for each
train, and given the limited space available for the underground terminal,
efficiency was paramount.
Work on the Boca Chica Terminal, due to its underground nature, would take far
longer than the work needed for the Hershey terminal. The terminal would not
be completed and at its full operational capacity until over a year after the
official opening of the tunnel in 1997.
As construction went on in the Florida Strait and on the terminals ashore, the
design and development process for the tunnel’s trains kicked into high gear.
In February 1990, the design was finalized for the high-speed electric trains
that would run through the tunnel. Their engineering had not been an easy
task.
Several different factors affected the ultimate design of the streamlined
stainless-steel trains that today travel from Boca Chica to Hershey. Cost,
efficiency, speed, capacity, and reliability issues all had their say in the
development process. The initial design specifications, drawn up during the
1982 request for bids, called for a “high-speed electric train service
connecting the United States to Cuba.” “High speed,” as indicated in the
contract, was defined as “average speeds above 120 miles an hour.” To meet
that requirement, Tunnel Company engineers drew up a magnetically-levitated
monorail system that was on the bleeding edge of early 1980s technology. The
monorail was the wave of the future – or so everyone said – and a monorail had
a sense of “the future is now” that the Company’s marketing department loved
and a sense of simplicity that the engineers appreciated.
But as tunnel construction costs rose and the anticipated train development
costs rose as well, the engineers in charge of designing the train were forced
to search for alternatives. They looked towards Europe for answers, much as
Europe had looked to America in inspiration for the development of the
Chunnel. There, the Tunnel Company’s engineers found the French TGV, a
modification of which was being planned for operation in the Chunnel and in
England. This was a standard wheeled train that needed none of the costly and
unreliable magnetic technology in order to achieve incredible speeds.
Beginning in 1988, General Electric began developing an American TGV in
response to a request by the Tunnel Company and by Amtrak, which had plans for
a high-speed rail service between American cities. With subsidies from the
“Rebuilding America” infrastructure improvement and urban redevelopment bills
passed by the Reagan administration and continued by President Jackson,
General Electric found high-speed locomotives to be financially lucrative and
jumped into the project with both feet.
A prototype locomotive was constructed in 1989, and testing continued
throughout the year. French engineers, including many who had designed the
TGV, were hired by General Electric in order to avoid making the same mistakes
that the French had done. Helped by the French engineers, work progressed
quickly and the design was frozen in February 1990. Working alongside the
General Electric engineers was a team from the Tunnel Company, which would
have to build the tracks that the train would ride on. Their task was made
easier by the decision to switch from a maglev monorail to a standard design
that was far more reliable and required much less electricity to operate.
Until the tunnel was fully completed, however, work on the train tracks could
not begin. The train tubes were being used by construction equipment and for
transporting supplies needed for the construction. Only when the tunnel was
complete could finishing work begin. Until then, the train design and
manufacturing process continued.
In late 1991, the first of the production locomotives left the General
Electric assembly line in Pennsylvania. With the tunnel not yet ready, General
Electric engineers busied themselves with the design of the train cars and on
improving the performance of the locomotive. This process eventually resulted
in a top speed of over 140 miles an hour for the Tunnel’s locomotives – 20
miles an hour greater than had been originally specified in the contract.
The train cars were designed for comfort as well as performance. Passenger
cars were laid out to maximize passengers’ personal space, with a row of two
seats on each side of the central aisle. Ample room was left for later
customization and changes in the interior design, which would naturally take
place over the anticipated 50-year lifetime of the train car. The design for
the automobile cars didn’t come as easily.
As people in Europe, America, and around the world celebrated or mourned the
collapse of the Soviet Union and the ending of the Cold War, several rounds of
train car design and re-design took place. The goal in all this, as with the
elevators at Boca Chica, was to maximize the efficiency of the loading and
unloading of the automobiles into and out of the train cars designated for
their use. To speed the loading and unloading process, the engineers at
General Electric, assisted by the team from the Tunnel Company, came up with
an inventive design.
The automobile cars of the Tunnel trains today feature sliding sides that
allow the entire left and right sides of the car to be lifted up and away,
allowing easy access to the interior of the cars. To speed loading, the floors
of the cars feature platforms that slide outward. Automobiles are driven on to
the platforms (which are level with the raised concrete deck of the terminal’s
automobile docks) and parked nose-to-tail. The platforms are then retracted
into the train car and the process repeated for the upper level of the train
car. The sides of the train car are then lowered and the train car is ready to
travel. To unload the car, the process is reversed. A trained crew can load an
individual train car in 5-10 minutes, and several cars can be loaded or
unloaded simultaneously.
By the autumn of 1992, the first cars and locomotives were mated for testing
and trials. Training for conductors, loaders, train engineers, and everyone
else needed to run the trains began, and procedures for the loading and
unloading of the train cars – the most difficult portion of the operation –
were worked out by trial and error. This work was critically important to the
completion of the tunnel project, but went largely unnoticed by the general
public. Overshadowing everything was the laying of tunnel sections, the
process of which reached a climax in 1992.
The addition of the Christopher Columbus to the tunnel-laying process greatly
speeded construction during the four years that followed its addition to the
construction fleet in November 1988. When the Columbus finished its
weight-laying duties and was reassigned to the construction fleet, just over
one-third of the tunnel had been laid down in three years. Between 1988 and
1992, improved procedures, better equipment, more experienced workers, and the
addition of the Columbus to the fleet saw the tunnelers lay sixty miles of
undersea sections in the time it had taken the Glomar Explorer to lay less
than half that.
And on November 1, 1992, it all came to an end. In an elaborate ceremony
reminiscent of the one that had taken place seven years earlier, the final
tunnel section was laid down and welded into place. President Jackson, former
Vice-President Gonzales (now CEO of the Tunnel Company), the President of
Cuba, and dozens of other government officials were on hand for the ceremony.
Unlike the ceremony in 1985, this one took place without a hitch. The
Christopher Columbus lowered the enormous set of steel tubes with its crane,
and the section was welded into place less than four hours later. By the end
of the day, the section had been pumped out, interim covers torched away, and
a second ceremony took place one hundred feet below the ocean as a motorcade
transported President Jackson (who would vault to an electoral victory a few
days later) and party from Boca Chica to Cuba while a similar motorcade
brought the President of Cuba through the tunnel to meet him. The two men met
in a ceremony at the halfway point, where still more ceremonies took place.
Many historians have speculated that the gala ceremony helped propel President
Jackson to a victory in the 1992 presidential election just a few days later.
More cynical observers have speculated that the gala ceremony came about
because the election was just a few days off.
Regardless of the circumstances that led to the staging of the event, the deed
was done. Seven years after the first tunnel section was laid, the last slid
into place. It was a critical landmark in the construction of the Tunnel. But
the work was not yet complete. The tunnel was still a hollow shell, a steel
tube stretching over a hundred miles through the coral of Boca Chica, the
water of the Florida Strait, and the soil of Cuba. No tracks had yet been
installed, no permanent cabling had been strung, and the vast majority of the
tunnel was still dark, lit only by temporary portable lanterns. So incomplete
was the tunnel that during the motorcade that brought President Jackson to
meet with the President of Cuba, there had been a danger that the cars of the
motorcade would emit so much carbon dioxide that they would create a fatal
atmosphere within the tunnel – the ventilation system had not yet been
installed. Fortunately, that event didn’t come to pass and the motorcade and
ceremony passed without incident.
But even as the final welds were made and construction equipment rearranged,
the first rumblings of something wrong began to surface. It had taken seven
years to complete the laying of the tunnel. In that time, French and British
engineers had planned, dug, and finished the Channel tunnel in Europe. Though
not yet completed, the Chunnel had finished its digging a year earlier. Now,
several magazines and newspapers in the United States were questioning why the
project was taking so long. The quick answer was that the Tunnel was nearly
four times as long as the Chunnel, and so needed more time to complete. This
didn’t answer all the questions, however. The original schedule had called for
the tunnel to be completed in 1990, with an opening in 1994. This schedule was
now out the window.
In addition, the cost of construction had been enormous. Of the $37.4 billion
original estimate by American Bridge, approximately $32 billion had been spent
on construction. In 1992, there was a real danger that the completion of the
tunnel would require far more money than had originally been planned. And over
the next year, American Bridge did apply for an additional $5 billion in
government loans. Owing to the increasing pressure on the tunnel project, the
loans came from the American and Cuban governments reluctantly and with
several conditions attached.
With the money in hand and the tunnel shell complete, work began on the
interior in earnest. The first priority for the workers was the installation
of secondary and auxiliary pumps in each of the tunnel sections. The primary
ballast and anti-flooding pumps had been installed during the welding process
in order to handle the occasional leaks and condensation that appeared in even
the best-welded tunnel. Auxiliary pumps were needed for safety concerns, and
the electrical wiring needed to operate the pumps and lights within the tunnel
was also a priority.
The work was slow, dark, and potentially dangerous. In 1993, a mislaid cutting
torch set electrical insulation ablaze thirty miles south of Boca Chica Key
and a hundred feet below the surface of the Florida Strait. Three workers
perished in the resulting fire, all as a result of smoke inhalation. Fire
suppression systems, which were planned for the tunnel, had not yet been
activated. The incident sparked a series of lawsuits that resulted in costly
payments to the families of the deceased. The event also created a storm of
negative publicity and American Bridge was forced to invest in improved safety
equipment for tunnel workers, further escalating costs.
On May 6, 1994, the Channel Tunnel opened for operation in Europe to enormous
acclaim. The Florida Strait Tunnel, meanwhile, was still far from being
finished. Track laying began in September 1994, and progressed relatively
quickly. A set of eight locomotives and accompanying cars were purchased from
General Electric for a sum of $1.2 billion. Their high cost was representative
of the problems that had arisen during their design as well as the complex
nature of the high-speed trains.
The cost was high enough to hamper the development of an Amtrak high-speed
rail link between Washington D.C. and New York City, though one would
eventually be built several years later. The subsidies provided by the
government and the initial investment provided by the Tunnel Company helped to
make the project financially possible.
In simulators in Cuba and the United States, train operators learned their
trade and loading and unloading techniques were refined and improved. The
terminals in Boca Chica and Hershey were improved, expanded, and refined. The
General Electric Fusion locomotives were loaded on to ships and shipped to
Hershey via sea. The irony wasn’t lost on many of the people aboard or the
engineers in charge of the shipment. After slight complications, the
locomotives and cars arrived in Hershey in the summer of 1995. There, they
were mated in their forward-and-back configuration – locomotives were needed
at the front and back of the train, as there was no room to turn around at the
Boca Chica end of the tunnel – and testing continued.
By 1996, the Tunnel Company was burning through money at a fantastic rate. Not
only was construction continuing on the interior of the tunnel, but the tunnel
shell had to be maintained regularly and the terminals at Boca Chica and
Hershey were still not finished. With the money running out and time quickly
becoming a factor, the Tunnel Company Board of Directors and CEO Carlito
Gonzales made a critical decision. The tunnel would open to the public on July
1, 1997 – no matter what.
To ensure that the tunnel would be completed in time for that drop-dead
opening date, completion of the tunnel was prioritized over everything else.
Non-essential work on the terminals was dropped in favor of putting more
workers into the tunnel and on track construction projects. Tickets went on
sale to the general public on August 1, 1996, and immediately became a hot
commodity. Though most of the first day’s tickets had already been sold in the
preliminary offering that had taken place in 1987, Americans and Cubans alike
jumped at the chance to purchase tickets for what promised to be a historic
event.
Unlike the 1987 sale, which took place primarily through licensed dealers, the
public sale of tickets in 1996 began through the Tunnel Company itself. The
Company even utilized the novel concept of online ticket sales using the
Internet, then a new concept in marketing. Such was the demand for tickets
that the Company’s Web site immediately crashed at the opening of ticket
sales, requiring a restructuring of its online connectivity and structure.
The 1996 U.S. Presidential election saw Vice President Albert Gore fall by a
narrow margin to Republican Lamar Alexander. Alexander campaigned on a
campaign of “fiscal responsibility,” and deplored the expensive
government-funded programs of the Reagan and Jackson years. One of his prime
targets was the Florida Strait Tunnel, which he saw as a government
boondoggle. While he declared that he wouldn’t cancel any of the existing
loans for the project, he did promise that he would veto any additional loans
for the project, saying in a bowdlerization of President Truman’s famous
phrase, “the bucks stop here.”
That declaration made the Tunnel Company’s determination to open the tunnel on
July 1 come hell or high water all the greater. From January 20, 1997 – the
date of Alexander’s inauguration – there were less than seven months left
until the scheduled opening of the tunnel. For all intents and purposes, those
seven months would be a race. It was a race between the construction workers
and the concrete deadline, a race between the company’s budget and the end of
the government loans, and a race among the media organizations covering it as
to who could generate the most hype.
The first and second of those races looked to be ones the Tunnel Company could
win. For all the problems and expenses incurred during the finishing of the
tunnel shell, the five years that had been spent finishing the tunnel hadn’t
been entirely wasted. The construction workers had become extremely proficient
at all the vagaries that working in a steel tube 100 feet below the surface of
the ocean entailed. Over the last seven months, work progressed at a rate as
fast as anything else during construction. The second race – the race against
the company’s deficits – also looked to be a winnable one. In the four months
between the opening of ticket sales and Alexander’s inauguration, the Tunnel
Company had sold over $100 million in tickets. This was but a drop in the
bucket when compared with the Company’s multi-billion-dollar debt, but it was
a positive sign of things to come. Not even ticket prices far higher than
1987’s speculative offering could deter Americans and Cubans alike from
purchasing tickets in substantial numbers. It’s also important to note that
the ticket sales until 1998 were based on an expectation that the trains would
not be able to run at full capacity due to work needed to bring the tunnel and
terminals to completion.
As the final months and weeks ticked down to the grand opening, many of the
tunnel’s systems were brought on line for the first time and the final bugs
were ironed out. The brand-new I-95 extension to Boca Chica from Miami was
opened fully to traffic for the first time, and drivers could now enjoy six
uninterrupted lanes of asphalt between Miami and Boca Chica. Even this large
expanse of road would eventually prove to be inadequate for traffic, and in
the ten years since the tunnel’s opening, the highway has since been widened
to eight lanes, with plans on the board for ten. Key West, which had gotten
over its initial reluctance over the tunnel’s construction long before,
planned a week-long gala celebration in commemoration, and even President
Alexander, a firm opponent of the tunnel’s perceived waste, wasn’t above
participating in the events.
With two weeks left to go before the tunnel’s opening, the entire construction
crew and Tunnel Company were shaken by sad news from Havana. Andres Aguero,
the grandfather of the tunnel project, had passed away at the age of 92. Since
his removal from his position as the CEO of the Tunnel Company and stroke in
1988, he had been bedridden, confined to a hotel suite with a view of Havana
Harbor where he had an excellent view of the ships of the construction fleet
arriving and departing. Interestingly, both Manuel Cereijo and Carlito
Gonzales saw fit to keep Aguero informed of every development of the
construction process during their tenures as head of the Tunnel Company. When
Aguero passed away on June 14, he died knowing that his dream would be
reality.
Aguero’s death shook many of the long-time workers, particularly the Cuban
workers, who saw Aguero as a grandfather figure. Many of the older workers,
upon seeing a younger worker misbehaving or doing something incorrectly, would
admonish the worker with the phrase, “Andres wouldn’t like it.” That was
usually enough to get the worker to change his ways. The death, largely
ignored in the American media but covered widely in Cuba, hung over the
construction site like a cloud, tempering the imminent opening of the tunnel
with a touch of sadness. The news also lent a touch of macabre humor to the
repeated bugs that kept cropping up during the testing of various parts of the
tunnel. Whenever something broke or went wrong, the person involved would
simply shrug his or her shoulders and say, “Andres must’ve done it.”
With one week to go, Andres pulled his most spectacular prank during the
powering up of the rail system within the tunnel. Megawatts of electricity
were drawn into the tunnel during the first full power-up of the electric rail
system. For five minutes, everything went smoothly. Sensors along the full
hundred-mile length of track recorded correct voltages. In the sixth minute,
something went wrong. A faulty piece of electric wire caused a short that
tripped circuit breakers and caused a cascading chain of errors that resulted
in fuses blown across the length of the tunnel, set three transformers on
fire, and knocked out power to all of the Florida Keys south of the Miami-Dade
county line.
Tunnel Company crews went into high gear to fix the problem. Hundreds of fuses
had to be replaced, new transformers had to be installed, and the source of
the initial problem had to be found and fixed. With over ten thousand miles of
wiring in the tunnel, this was no small task. Fortunately for those involved,
the short had left a gigantic scorch mark along the inside of the tunnel
shell, and when workers began a foot-by-foot inspection of the wiring, it was
easily observed. Unfortunately, it had taken three days of examination to
reach that point in the search process.
With just four days left until the grand opening and still more repairs and
tests to be done, Tunnel Company managers were in a frenzy. The short-circuit
had left things in a complete mess. There simply wasn’t time to do everything
that needed to be done and test everything that needed to be tested. Even
working four 24-hour days wouldn’t be enough. The workers had to try, though.
News of the catastrophe eventually filtered up to Carlito Gonzales and the
rest of the Board of Directors of the Tunnel Company. Clearly, something had
to be done. But what? The grand opening was in three days, and the tunnel
wouldn’t be ready. It would be an absolute disaster to have an event and have
no one be able to travel through the tunnel. That left only one solution –
moving the concrete, unmovable deadline. In a unanimous vote, the Tunnel
Company board of directors agreed to push the grand opening back for 24 hours.
That would be enough time, they hoped, to get everything ready for the biggest
day of their lives.
Those last five days saw thousands of men working around the clock to fix the
damage that had been done and to conduct last-minute tests on everything from
the electrical connections to the railroad track to the toilets in the
passenger cars. The 24-hour delay was played up enormously in the global
media, and CNN put together a quick series on “The Tunnel: Is it safe?” The
Tunnel Company’s stock slumped on the news, and many investors held their
breaths. If the delay was indicative of problems with the tunnel, and if it
was followed by other delays, the future wouldn’t be bright for their
investments. Still, most investors held on to their shares – by and large,
they were in it for the long haul, and had decided a decade ago, after Black
Tuesday, that they would see this thing through to the end.
The morning of July 2 dawned cloudy, and it seemed as if the ceremonies would
be dampened by a rainstorm. But by 9:00 a.m., the clouds had parted and the
sun was shining through. An hour later, when the ceremony began, the sky was
brilliantly clear with white, wispy clouds soaring above Boca Chica. Speeches
by every major participant in the project followed, but the heat of the day
kept most of them thankfully brief. An estimated 100,000 people were on hand,
cramming the island well beyond its capacity, to see President Lamar Alexander
cut the ceremonial ribbon alongside the President of Cuba.
At 12:00 noon on July 2, 1997, the Florida Strait Tunnel was pronounced
officially open. Twelve years of construction, twenty years of planning and
imagination, and the effort of tens of thousands of men came to an end.
Together, the United States and Cuba, with the assistance of foreign bankers,
created the world’s second-largest single construction. Only the Great Wall of
China was longer, and it had required hundreds of years to complete and
required the sacrifice of tens of thousands of lives. Now, the tunnel would
stand as a monument to human ingenuity and a triumph over impossible odds.
The passengers on the first train were the dignitaries who had participated in
the ceremony as well as a select number of people who purchased advance
tickets in 1987, over a decade previously. The first paying passenger was a
gentleman from Bozeman, Montana, who had waited in line for six hours back in
1987 in order to be the first person to purchase a ticket. Over the next 12
hours, thousands of other passengers would travel the same route between Boca
Chica and Hershey. To maximize the number of passengers traveling in the first
week, no automobiles were transported until July 10. Trains ran entirely with
passenger cars, and were shuttled to and from their destinations via buses.
The time spent working out procedures for maximizing efficiency in the loading
and unloading process turned out to be well-spent. Although problems did
develop – particularly from passengers who didn’t follow the carefully
laid-out procedures – they were largely made good by the Tunnel Authority’s
workers, who had undergone several months of training. Modifications were made
to procedures based on the experience of those earlier travelers, and just as
the tunnel’s workers had gradually improved the pace at which they built the
tunnel, so too did the Tunnel Authority improve the speed with which
passengers and cars could be loaded and unloaded.
The Boca Chica Terminal was finally completed in early 1999, almost two full
years after the official opening. Most of the decorations and aesthetic
features of the terminal were not yet installed at the time of the opening,
and had to be completed as space and time allowed. Things as fundamental as
the terminal’s bathrooms weren’t finished in July 1997, but were eventually
completed before 1999.
The Tunnel faced the biggest challenge of its short life in September 1998
when Hurricane Georges struck the Florida Keys just north of Boca Chica. High
winds, a high storm surge, and heavy rains wracked the Boca Chica Terminal and
forced a halting of Tunnel operations. The halt didn’t come about due to
safety concerns with the tunnel, but because high winds prevented automobile
traffic from reaching Boca Chica from Miami. Though winds reached 105 miles an
hour in Key West, the underground structure of the terminal escaped damage
entirely. Large amounts of rainwater and seawater from the storm surge did
enter the tunnel, the bilge space constructed below the terminal filled its
purpose. Though it had never been intended to fill its function after the
completion of construction, the bilge prevented seawater from flooding the
tunnel itself and causing damage to the tracks.
Following the storm, improvements were made to the terminal to prevent further
flooding and protect the tunnel against even larger storm surges from future
storms. These improvements proved their worth during 2005’s Hurricane Wilma,
when the Boca Chica Terminal was again struck by storm surge from a nearby
hurricane.
The two storms stopped traffic for a brief time, but traffic continued to
flow, and continues to flow at a staggering rate even today, a full decade
after the opening of the tunnel to the general public. Ten million passengers
a year pass through the tunnel annually, despite tolls higher than any other
crossing on Earth. The Tunnel’s initial multi-billion-dollar price is now
scheduled to be entirely paid off by 2030 if passenger rates continue at
present levels. Improvements in efficiency and traffic flow have increased the
amount of passengers able to funnel through the tunnel far beyond initial
plans, but practical considerations have caused potential passenger capacity
to level out.
Since its opening, the tunnel has inspired several similar projects. The
success of the Suspended Immersed Tube design has inspired plans for tunnels
across the Strait of Messina, connecting Spain and Morocco, and even plans for
a tunnel connecting Cuba to the Yucatan Peninsula in Mexico. Such a tunnel
would cut hours off the time needed to drive from the East Coast of the United
States to Central America and South America. Central American investment would
be crucial to such a project, but this is as yet unlikely to occur.
Regardless of what projects come after it, the Florida Strait Tunnel will
stand as a pioneer in tunnel design and infrastructure improvement. Connecting
Florida and Cuba, the tunnel has provided vacations for tens of millions of
North Americans and has provided a massive injection of trade and commerce
into the Cuban economy. The Jose Marti Towers, the twin 60-story “green”
skyscrapers now rising into the air above Havana owe their existence as much
to the tunnel as to the loans and workers integral to their construction.
But beyond even these grand projects, the story of the Florida Strait Tunnel
is a story of individuals. The people who designed it, the workers who built
it, the bankers and investors who paid for it, and the passengers who use it –
they’ve all had their effect on the history of the Tunnel and its continued
success. From the years of Henry Flagler and the Overseas Railway, the Florida
Strait has been instrumental in advancing the technology of transportation and
commerce. Now, and well into the future, engineers will look to the Florida
Strait Tunnel as an example of what can be done when high technology is
combined with big dreams.