Political Martyr Dostoyevsky
Shot
by Jeff Provine
Author
says: what if the reprieve arrived too late to save Fyodor Dostoyevsky
from the firing squad? muses Jeff Provine's on his excellent blog
This Day in
Alternate History. Please note that the opinions expressed in this post
do not necessarily reflect the views of the author(s).
On December 22nd 1849,
Please click the
icon to follow us on Facebook.on this day the political martyr
Fyodor Dostoyevsky (pictured) was shot by a firing squad in St.
Petersburg.
Dostoyevsky's childhood led his great mind into the only option for its
escape: revolution. His father, a raging alcoholic, was a retired military
surgeon who moved his family into a small apartment on the grounds of
Moscow's Mariinsky Hospital for the Poor, where he practiced. The hospital
was surrounded by bitter poverty such as an orphanage for the abandoned
and an asylum for the insane. Such conditions would be forever impressed
upon the young Fyodor. Suffering from epilepsy himself, Fyodor would defy
his parents' wishes and explore the hospital gardens, visiting with
patients and building a sense of hope out of such bitterness.
"For all practical purposes, Russia was defeated by
Germany in our own World War I. the separate peace treaty the new Soviet
regime signed with Germany in early 1918 sliced away the Baltics, the
Ukraine and other important imperial possessions. One reason Stalin was
willing to do a deal with Hitler in 1939 was that it let him regain lost
pieces of Russia's prerevolutionary empire, the Baltic republics and
eastern Poland in particular. " - reader's commentsAt age 16, after
the death of his mother, Dostoyevsky was sent to military engineering
school, and his father died soon after. He fell in love with literature
and suffered through mathematics enough to manage a commission, eventually
becoming a lieutenant. Dostoyevsky left the military in 1843 and turned
fulltime to literature, translating Balzac and creating his own fiction.
His first published work came in 1846 as a novella entitled Poor Folk, and
Dostoyevsky was thrown into literary fame. Fame was fleeting; his next
work, The Double, met with frowns of disappointment.
His explorations of schizophrenia and literary experimentation were given
up after The Double, and Dostoyevsky pushed himself toward the trials of
poverty that he had known so well. He joined the Petrashevsky Circle, a
reading and discussion group of progressives in St. Petersburg. While they
made some movement, there was no great organization for change beyond
theory.
"I know several literature majors who'd thank God
fasting for this scenario. " - reader's commentsAcross Europe in
1848, however, there was much action for change. The Revolutions of 1848
spread across the continent, and Czar Nicholas feared an uprising in
Russia. He had easily quashed the 1825 Decembrist Revolt and ended Peter
the Great's ideals of Westernization, instead turning back toward
orthodoxy. With challenges to autocracy rising in many other empires,
Nicholas decided to end the revolution before it could take place by
rounding up any progressively minded intellectual. The Petrashevsky Circle
was among the groups arrested and put through public mock execution
rituals, displays in which the populace could see the might of the Czar's
will but also his grace at giving reprieves.
Dostoyevsky himself was arrested April 23, 1849, and, on November 16,
sentenced to death by firing squad. After the mock execution, he assumed
this would be another of the Czar's displays, and it was generally agreed
that he would receive a reprieve. However, due to bureaucratic bungling in
the delivery of the reprieve, Dostoyevsky was shot by order of a zealous
commander.
"I guess, the space time continuum would have
burst-ed the nearest Black hole, and ignighted the anti materreserve that
are surpressed deep in the center of our solar systems sun! Just kidding,
I like some of those movies that alter events like Star Trek 4, and right
now in real life someone took Bin laden into a future jail to be executed,
and that's why we can't find him. " - reader's commentsShock
settled over St. Petersburg, and Dostoyevsky's writings spread through the
city and, then, the country. Many historians suggest that not all of the
writings were his, but his depictions of the lives of serfs and the poor
are recognized as genuine. Propaganda or not, the works ignited the
Russian people as they discussed around fires and over glasses of vodka.
Nicholas, refusing to appear weak, repressed those calling for government
apology on what was increasingly viewed as a terrorist assassination.
That spring, Russian Mikhail Bakunin escaped from imprisonment while being
handed over to Austrian authorities for his organization of the Dresden
Uprising the year before. Aided by Russian revolutionist leaders, the 1850
Rising began as Bakunin arrived and announced the liberation of the serfs.
Pandering to Slavophile ideals and collectivism, the bureaucracy was
overthrown, aristocracy and Jewish farmers alike around the country were
slaughtered, and Nicholas was violently ushered off the throne in favor of
a much weakened Alexander II constitutionally bound by a council of
advisers, Bakunin among them.
Monarchs in Europe debated sending military aid to the Czar, but renewed
troubles with revolts in their own empires kept them from assembling a
campaign. New stability would be founded in nationalism, citing the best
for one's people and country. Strong, central leadership struck both the
West and Russia, but the return to the mir, or collective village, style
of living would create a sharp ideological division between the two. As
the West modernized, Russians settled into orthodoxy, ultimately preparing
for swift military defeat by Imperial Germany after the turn of the
century.
Author
says in reality Dostoyevsky received his reprieve. He was exiled to
Siberia, being transformed by suffering through new levels of poverty, and
then returned to St. Petersburg, writing some of the greatest works in the
Russian language, Notes from Underground, Crime and Punishment,
and The Brothers Karamazov. To view guest historian's comments on
this post please visit the
Today in Alternate History web site.
Jeff Provine, Guest Historian of
Today in Alternate History, a Daily Updating Blog of Important Events In
History That Never Occurred Today. Follow us on
Facebook, Myspace and
Twitter.
Imagine what would be, if history had occurred a bit
differently. Who says it didn't, somewhere? These fictional news items
explore that possibility. Possibilities such as America becoming a Marxist
superpower, aliens influencing human history in the 18th century and Teddy
Roosevelt winning his 3rd term as president abound in this interesting
fictional blog.
Sitemetre
|